|
New to Ham Radio?
My Profile
Community
Articles
Forums
News
Reviews
Friends Remembered
Strays
Survey Question
Operating
Contesting
DX Cluster Spots
Propagation
Resources
Calendar
Classifieds
Ham Exams
Ham Links
List Archives
News Articles
Product Reviews
QSL Managers
Site Info
eHam Help (FAQ)
Support the site
The eHam Team
Advertising Info
Vision Statement
About eHam.net
|
Portable Shelter
Do not contact (N4ZOU)
on
July 6, 2005
View comments about this article!
Low cost, easy transport, Portable shelter.
After my "Rolling Shack" article I had many personal requests about writing an article about building a communications shelter that could be transported to the emergency site in the bed of a truck. These people did not want to pull a camper as they already were using a utility trailer to transport towers and antennas. Some stated that the trailer incorporated a crank up tower so pulling a camper was out of the question. Also noted was the problem of modern tents. They keep the bugs off you and that's about all! I started looking at surplus military tents. The starting price of a used, in need of repair 12' X 12' canvas tent is $750 plus shipping and handling. Cabelas carries real tents made of canvas but the cost is also prohibitive. http://www.cabelas.com/cabelas/en/templates/index/index-display.jhtml?id=cat550002&navAction=jump&navCount=1&parentId=cat20075&parentType=category&cmCat=MainCatcat20075 The second problems with these tents are there weight. You're going to need a 12-person squad to put them up and take them down! Needless to say you're going to be lucky if anyone is there to help when you arrive at the emergency site. Researching emergency shelters on the Internet I discovered Geodesic Domes are a very popular shelter design and for good reasons. Construction materials may be lightweight and portable and the Dome when erected is very strong using these materials. No special materials or tools are required for construction; everything required is available with one stop shopping at a local building supply store. Domes when erected and properly anchored can withstand hurricane force winds without sustaining damage.
Lets start off with shelter size. You want to be able to stand up and have room for several people, gear, and at least one bed. You also don't want the dissembled shelter taking up precious vehicle transport space. A very good size is a 2V 5-foot radius Dome made of 1/2" EMT Conduit. The 2V dome requires 65 sections of conduit. This conduit is manufracted in standard 10' sections. Using the 5' radius 2V dome requires the use of two different lengths and allows cutting the 10' sections three times to obtain 3 sections of the required lengths. These sections will be called A and B. For a 5-foot radius Dome A length between the centers of the bolt holes in each end will be 37.08" and B will be 32.784". This is NOT the measured length of the conduit pipes! They will need to be about 2" longer than the measured hole lengths giving about 1" of pipe length between the center of the hole and the end of the conduit. It is critical that holes in all conduit lengths be the same for all A sections and all B sections so the dome will have the proper Geodesic shape. Speaking of the shape, here is what 2V dome looks like.

This is a good choice between the roundness of the dome shape and the number of pipes required to build it. This drawing also shows where the A and B pipes are assembled.
Time to start fabrication of the A and B pipe sections. You will need to make a jig for marking the required lengths of pipe for accurate cutting and after all pipes are cut you may use the same jig for drilling all the holes.
If you do not have a drill press you should consider buying or borrowing one now! You will also need some way of flattening the ends of the conduit pipes before drilling.
Here is a picture of a 10' section of conduit laying in the jig for length marking.
Here is how you cut it, NO don't even think about using a hacksaw! You will make ugly cuts and screw up the pipe when you clamp it down in the vice while sawing on it. Using a plumbers pipe cutter guarantees a perfect cut every time!
Now you need to flatten the ends so there ready to drill. Use caution when you start to flatten the pipe. You can't just stick it in the press or vice any old way. Look carefully at the pipe and you will find a welded seam. If this seam ends up at the corner of the flattened pipe it will split and if you drill through the seam it will split there as well. Just put the seam at a 45-degree angle under the press, vice, or hammer and the seam will cause you no problems.
Ok, conduit sections are cut to length, the ends are flattened, and were ready to drill! A simple jig will ensure all your holes are the exact length they need to be.
The last process involves removing burs and sharp edges and paint. Yes, I know. Conduit is galvanized and no need to paint it; except where you cut and drilled it! It will quickly rust at the ends. Another advantage is using two different colors between the A and B pipes. This will save you from considerable confusion and headaches later, I promise! You may paint the entire pipe or just dip the ends in the paint can.
Assembly of the dome elements is easy. All connections at each hub use a single bolt, washer, and nut.
When you start to assemble the dome don't tighten the nuts tight, make sure the joints can move a little so the dome elements can flex and automatically self align as you assemble them. After all elements are in place then go back and clamp them down tight. You will be amazed at how rigid the dome frame has become!
At this point you need to secure the dome frame to the ground. The cheap and easy way is to use "U" shaped rebar and a sledgehammer.
Domes roll and fly very well in the wind and they're so rigid they can go for miles before they come apart leaving a path of destruction in their wake! Stick the rebar in the ground about 2' deep and at every corner.
Now you need to cover it. The frame looks pretty sitting there but it won't keep the rain and wind off you without a cover! Use that cheap blue (or other color) tarp available everywhere. Here's how to do it.
Tarp and dome, approximate relative sizes.
You can narrow the top (once the tarp's bottom edge is attached to the dome) by taking one large pleat on each side at the top. You end up with a trapezoid. Use multiple trapezoids to cover your dome.
You can use some bungee cords and/or rope and/or bungee balls to secure the two closest grommets of the top edge and the two corner grommets with forces in opposite directions, so that the top tarps hold their positions.
When tarps cross each other, you can attach to any of these points:
A grommet on an already mounted tarp.
The base struts of the dome are always viable, even if you have to reach them with a length of rope. To cut synthetic rope: wrap with tape, cut, burn ends with lighter until fibers fuse, remove tape.
To another bungee or rope that is itself secured to something.
Setup time depends on how much help you have! This 5' dome is easy for one person to setup. The key is to have most of the pipes already bolted together and loose for transport. Also assemble it a few times and you quickly get the hang of putting it up. You should be able to go from transport box to shelter in less than an hour. If you have a large group and want a larger dome shelter this site will take care of all your construction requirements. http://www.desertdomes.com/index.html
Material cost of this dome should be less than $150 for conduit, hardware, tarps, and bungee cords. This would also make an impressive Field day setup for 2006!
I wanted to get this article posted due to the requests I have had as soon as possible and so I used pictures from the Internet, which allowed me to get it here very quickly.
This article has expired. No more comments may be added.
|
Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by N8CPA on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
F. Buckminster Fuller would be proud. Domes look cool, and they have spatially efficient foot prints.
But the assembly process probably involves too much manpower for portable application. I think a better choice would be a complete "portable garage" kit, for about the same price at Lowes and other outlets. Most of the ones I've seen have frame works capable of supporting the additional weight of tarps for sidewalls, if necessary. Use common sense in your selection.
Another choice, i.e. what I use, is an 8 x 11 portable backyard "pavilion." We reinforce the joints of the sectionalized poles with duct tape, to support the added weight of a 20 x 40 tarp, a slightly smaller one would be better--possible winter project. The tarp is only half stretched over the roof, until the rain comes. Just have ropes through the front grommets to stake down so the wind doesn't blow it away.
I also recommend not letting the sidewalls all the way to the ground, i.e use a tarp small enough, to allow the shelter to "breathe" and have fans inside to maintain air circulation. It can get stuffy in there.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by W6TH on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
.
I have been using a pup tent and works great for me.
.:
|
|   |
|
Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by N4ZOU on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
The portable backyard pavilion is an option if you wait for the storm to completely pass and a second storm does not hit while your still operating in the emergency shelter. Remember what happened in Florida during the 2004 hurricane season? The cheap pavilion frames will not withstand high winds even with there tarps removed. The tarps may be removed from a dome and left in place and it will still be there (unless an automobile is blown over it) when you return to continue emergency operations.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by KC7JDS on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
I take it that when you say a 5 foot radius, that means it is 5 foot high at the center, and 10 foot in diameter.
For those of us that are somewhat "height-challanged, tall", what would be the design and dimensions of the components for a dome that is 6 or 7 foot radius/tall, and 12 or 14 foot diameter??
Oh, and BTW, where's the opening/entrance to the dome?
Otherwise, a good article, one that presents an alternative & makes you think.
B Woodman, kc7jds
|
|   |
|
Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by W5MEJ on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Good construction article - homebuilt geodesic domes indeed have possibilities, but there are also several drawbacks. They are much more difficult and time-consuming to set up than you make it sound!
You might also want to consider the size of the shelter a little more carefully. The 2V 5' radius dome you suggest won't meet your own design criteria, the ability to "stand up and have room for several people, gear, and at least one bed." It will be 5' tall at the apex, and a small cot or air mattress will take up most of the available floor space. Even a small desk for an operating position would be a tight fit, due to the small diameter (tight radius) of the dome.
Due to the small openings, the dome would have to be assembled and then set over the operating position, and moving any equipment in or out of the shelter would require removing the anchors and moving the dome.
Making the dome larger greatly increases the difficulty of setting it up. I've helped to set a couple of these things up, and they can really be a pain!
Chuck
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by W9WHE-II on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Why not just buy a Dome tent on sale for $125, pocket the difference and use the construction time to operate? In addition to being cheaper, A North Face, Columbia or mountain Hard Wear tent will also be waterproof and come with a rainfly!
And, for about $900 extra, you can get a NBC (Nuclear, Biologic and Chemical) suit to protect you!
W9WHE
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by W4ABX on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
There is always someone out there to take the wind out of your sails...
Excellent article, and the way things are looking, we might all be living in one in the near future. Beats the heck out of a cardboard box.
73,
W4ABX
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by WB2WIK on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
>RE: Portable Shelter Reply
by W6TH on July 6, 2005 Mail this to a friend!
I have been using a pup tent and works great for me.<
::My dog likes it, also.
::Nice article and interesting project, but I think real "emergency preparedness" is having more than one way to get Out of Dodge when the big one hits, regardless of the nature of the big one. Keep auto tanks full of gas and have planned multiple routes for evacuation.
WB2WIK/6
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by K3AN on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
I don't think the intention is to take wind out of anyone's sails. But good quality tents of over 100 square feet are available for as little as $250. Consumer's Reports magazine had a review of tents in the July 2005 issue.
Unless you intend to build a tent from scratch as a learning experience or a "labor of love," the cost of materials and a drill press will exceed the cost of a good quality purchased tent.
|
|   |
|
Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by WA9SVD on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
Yes, the "Geodome" as a structure was developed by Bucky (Buckminster) Fuller. But for those that are interested, the Southern Illinois University Design Department (Where Buckty Fuller taught) may still hold patent rights to the Geo-dome design, so any commercial product would have to do a patent search and possibly pay royalties before production begins.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by WA5ZNU on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
Didn't Bucky get the patent on the dome in 1954? Without an act of congress to extend it specially, it would have expired in 1971.
|
|   |
|
Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by N4ZOU on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Height of the dome is just a little over 9' so headroom is no problem, to get diameter from radius multiply by 2. Anything larger will need 3/4" or 1" EMT conduit and you will need help and a ladder to assemble it. Construction time and effort takes a quantum leap for every 10' larger radius!
A normal store bought tent or pavilion will not stand up to much of any harsh weather
Conditions. Also check the UV rating in the tents manual, after a few cumulative months of sun exposure it will be rotten and falling apart. This is fine for a week or two a year of typical "vacation" use but if your operating for more than a month in the sun your tent will need to be replaced. Plastic tarp suffers the same condition but it's easy and cheap to replace and no sewing required!
The patent ran out years ago. It was at that time many companies started manufacturing large home and commercial building kits and supplies. They're still very popular.
If you need ventilation simply leave off one of the tarps or fold it back.
Entrance is by stepping through the pipes. Alternately, you may leave off a Pentagram section and use larger pipe around this weakened section of the dome structure. Another option is to use 2 X 4 lumber glued and screwed with a hinged door.
The "cool" factor of this type of dome is extremely high, be prepared to entertain a high number of "guests" wanting a tour of the dome and equipment.
A metal structure dome also makes an outstanding ground system so top off your dome with your favorite vertical antenna!
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by WI7B on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Great introductory article, Scott. I also appreciate your referenced weblinks to Burning Man geodome designers. These folks have been "playa-testing" domes for a decade in the unforgiving gypsum deserts of northwestern Nevada.
These deserts can be subject to sudden bouts of fierce, unpredictable weather. Storm cells, fed by rising thermals that stream upward from the surrounding mountains, may arise in late afternoons or evenings and bring high winds, 200 foot "dust devils", lightning, and rain. Likewise, dust storms can prowl the playa in packs or sweep in a broadened front across the plain, producing white-out conditions and 70 mph gusts.
I have personally lived in these shelters under these conditions for a week and found them sturdy and safe. If you want, you can replace sections of the covering with clear plastic for windows. We will be locating the Special Event Station for Burning Man - N7B (http://n7bweb.net/) - from under one this year.
73,
---* Ken
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by K4RAF on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Nice, if you want to look like a geek, in a storm...
I have a 10' x 12' dome tent I bought for $99 15 years ago & has been used for field day. Rather than even buying the tools pictured (drill press, flat press, tubing cutter, etc), I'll buy another $99 tent & pocket the extra change.
Nice idea though, for ice fishing!!!
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by AD7FT on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
I do not understand how the dome can be 9 ft. tall with a 10 ft. diameter circle at the base, the "equator" of the complete circle. The dome is a half circle, right?
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by W6TH on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
.
WB2WIK/6 Steve,
I have used a Poncho. A blanketlike cloak having a hole in the center for the head. Sitting in a fox hole with about one foot of water. I prefer this over the pup tent as the water was very warm in the hole and was like being in a Sauna. A Sauna: A bathhouse or room for taking such a steam bath. Actually we called it a Fox Hole back in the good old days.
One thing I liked about a Fox Hole was we did not have to pay property taxes.
73, W6TH
.:
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by W6TH on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
.
Steve WB2WIK
One thing I liked about a Fox Hole was we did not have to pay property taxes.
The reason I did not have to pay property taxes for the Fox Hole was because I was in a foreign country trying to take over the country by force.
73, W6TH
.:
|
|   |
|
Much easier to buy a tent.
|
|
|
by WB4M on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
Being the lazy guy I am, I'd rather spend more money and get a nice pup tent than go through all that hassle.
|
|   |
|
Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by KD5DFM on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
now just make a version out of PVC pipe and duck tape and it will be a real ham dome ;-) john kd5dfm
|
|   |
|
Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by AC7KZ on July 6, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
Whoooooaaaa. Man, that's cool. It reminds me of the '70's when homes were made in the dome fashion.
|
|   |
|
Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by W5DCT on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
Nicely written article , great construction advice. only things are: you were worried about two main things, weight and cost. Conduit isnt light, it isnt cheap either. Not trying to knock the article but a 8x9 hiker dome tent weighs about 4 pounds,is big enough for a modest emergency set up, and costs about $40.00 at your local WallyLand. This is just my personal opinion ,I wont be out in a hurricane anyway folks , I'll wait for it to pass and then set up the tent. Just some simple words from a simple man. 73 KD5JZN
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by W6TH on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
.
My sympathy with a country who has experienced pain, grief by the London explosion.
May God be with you and comfort England.
Best regards, the W6TH family
.:
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by N8CPA on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Indeed, my thoughts and prayers for London as well. I told my wife that if the tubes were still as busy as when I was there, that the terrorists can call that mission a failure since the toll is so low.
As for the dome project: For most of us, the added cost of renting/buying the necessary jigs and tools to roll our own dome would probably take the cost well over the price for these: http://www.shelter-systems.com/relieftents/relief-tunnel.html
I am so tempted to buy one for next FD, even if it is in my backyard again.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by N8CPA on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
Just kidding, of course. If I could afford one of those things, I could buy another camper.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by W6TH on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
.
Just sit on a park bench with a Coleman stove and a pack of good beef hot dogs and a 65 foot of wire in the trees, what more can a hamster ask for.
Should it rain, lets head for home.
.:
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by WB9UDJ on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
As a student at Southern Illinois University way back farther than I like to remember, I had the pleasure to sit in on one of Bucky's lectures. He would come to the lecture hall without an idea of what he was going to lecture about. He just got on the stage and started talking. If he had an hour class scheduled he might talk for 3 hours and no one would leave. His lectures were standing room only as students would pile into the hall just to hear Bucky's fascinating talk.
Carbondale is the site of Bucky and his wife's house, the only one he ever owned if I remember correctly. True to form the geodesic design had leakage problems and thanks to the later tennants repairs were made to keep it standing.
SIU lost Bucky due to political infighting among his "Learned colleagues" who thought this "uneducated man who traveled all over the world instead of tending to his teaching" (this might not adhere to official reasoning but from friends in the Design college it is accepted as the real reason)was abusing the academic system. When Bucky's papers were offered to SIU with the stipulation that they had to be housed in and addition to Morris Library only for Fuller's papers the administration turned them down. That was a big mistake that they regret to this day.
He was a extremely interesting man. He only slept a few minutes every few hours and went around the clock. One time he got upset about something and refused to talk for about 18 months. His first revoluntary structural beam was designed when he was around 5 years old. His life time philosophy was to do more with less. He and his students tried to build a geodesic dome using venition blind slat material one time. It would just buckle and collapse. He decided that a little more stronger material was required. His Dymaxion automobile was a great idea that got scraped when it was involved in a crash that killed some passengers. The Dymaxion homes he designed that turned in the wind to get the best heating and cooling conditions were definitely in the more with less category. A couple of them still survive. Bucky envisioned a huge globe structure covered with lights that could be controlled in a way to show how various things were effecting our world. It would allowed scientists to walk around the large structure to observe how something affected the world as the lights made the data available visible and easily deciphered. Today we do that with our computers. He was truly one of the world's great thinkers.
|
|   |
|
Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by KC2MMI on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Scott, I hate to be another wet blanket but first you protest over cost and weight, then you mention a Cabela's page that has tents under $200 weighing 16 lbs., then you suggest that carrying around six hundred and fifty feet of electrical conduit IS NOT HEAVIER THAN A TENT??
Ignoring the extensive time for machining all your conduit, the weight of it all, the wonders of blue poly tarp, no doors, no screening....
I'm sorry but I just can't see it. I think the geodome is a great idea if you need a very rugged very permanent structure built quickly--but for fast temporary use?
I'd go back to looking at Cabela's wide range of options. Or better yet, contact your local state or county liason officers. Your state militia (aka "National Guard") headquarters should have field shelters available for disasters. Various big green tents, probably.<G> There's worse ways to go.
And I have to wonder, handling 130 pieces of cut pipe each with two nicely cut ends, how many cut hands your team would get putting that dome up? And how long the blue tarp would last, flopping around in the wind. It just seems like an answer in need of a problem.
Lots of camping stores rent "cabin tents" (the big army/outfitter's type) and you might be able to borrow them from a local scouting group or other source as well. But carrying around 650 feet of conduit?? Not me, not in my car.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by WA2JJH on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
>>>>>>>Didn't Bucky get the patent on the dome in 1954?
<<<<<<
I thought the famous bucky ball was a perfectly round bball composed of 4 single bond carbons.
I forgot the other super specs. i.e. the largest Psi/mass, volume, and many other material properties.
A VERY NICE SHAPE FOR A PORTA-SHACK.
That is the best shape to get a maximum sized shack using the least amount of material, and weight.
any eskimo's want to weigh in on this goemetricly perfect igloo?
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter -- Plus
|
|
|
by WA6BFH on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
I like the idea of this geodesic dome, and would like to build one as a sort of proto-type to play with some ideas for similar Ham ventures.
I try to go camping this time of year as often as possible, and will stay at a campground for as long as a week. Sometimes I will take my motor home but, more often, I just combine the use of a camper shell on the back of my truck with a small dome tent. This sort of shelter would seem to provide many advantages.
It would in addition to providing an excellent base structure, provide even the counterpoise for a rather diverse multi-band antenna system. The idea of covering the structure with a ‘blanket-work’ of tarps lends adaptability as both a closed tent, or simply a shade awning.
The multi-band antenna that I envision would be a sort of copper cactus “J”. This “J” (J-pole) would have individual feed sections for 23, 33, and 135 centimeter bands, as well as 2 and 6 Meters. The feedlines would terminate as ‘pigtails' a couple feet longer than the antenna. This would allow it to be transported as a modular unit, ready to erect. It would have an overall length of 16 feet (minus capacitive loading from the other elements and feed-lines) and load as a quarter-wave whip on 20 Meters, or a half-wave on 10 Meters. It would likely ‘fudge’ onto the HF bands in between with a reasonable SWR and moderate efficiency, and would be otherwise efficient on all bands between 6 Meters through 23 centimeters.
I can even foresee the addition of curved table-shelves that would mount on the walls, and also be suspended from overhead. This would allow for radio benches to surround the interior area, allowing for sleeping or storage below. This would also leave much of the center space available for group seating, or meetings etc. It sounds like it could be a good portable structure for field activities of the Tech Bench Elmers!
|
|   |
|
Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by NT4XT on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
The price is good. Aside from other more practical /P alternatives, nice article well done. Pictures!
Having the geodesic graphic on the front page of this site is an enhancement while it lasts. Cool.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by AE6IP on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
http://www.shelter-systems.com/relieftents/relieftents.html
$400 quantity 1, can be assembled by a single person, much lighter than conduit, packs into a small package, and is field proven.
Not the best expedition tent available, but one that's a good compromise.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by N0TONE on July 7, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Sounds like another example of a ham trying to homebrew something just to do so. I cannot imagine the need for this - it's yet another complexity standing between a ham, and his ability to contribute to assisting during an emergency.
If you only have one ham, then have him haul the antenna trailer, and operate from the vehicle. I've operated entire 48 hour contest, as well as a 12 hour stint from inside a flooded canyon, from the cab of a pickup truck. No need for an external shelter to haul around, add new failure modes, and require time to set up.
If you have two hams, and therefore might NEED a shelter to fit two people in, then you have one of those two people haul the antenna trailer, and the other one haul a small pop-up shelter that doesn't need an hour to set up.
Better yet, ditch the antenna trailer! I have never understood the need for them. I've done just fine with extensible fiberglass crappie poles and wire antennas, and have been "comm central" at three disasters using only the stuff I could pack in the trunk of a mid-sized sedan.
AM
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by KC9AWS on July 9, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
You could get this thing put up 2 weeks after the need for it had ceased! Spend less money and time and get one of those portable shelters from a farm supply store.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by WA2JJH on July 9, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
It could make a "randome" for cassagrain dish antenna's!
more importantly......what band will it load up on!
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by KA4KOE on July 11, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"Sounds like another example of a ham trying to homebrew something just to do so. I cannot imagine the need for this - it's yet another complexity standing between a ham, and his ability to contribute to assisting during an emergency."
Ever hear of "Amateur" radio...where one does something just for the pure joy of it? Kudos to the guy for sharing his nice project with us.
We all need to lighten up kiddies, or people like our author will quit writing for this forum and this website will quickly become a barren wasteland, populated only by a few bitter, nihilistic, bomb-throwers.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by AE6IP on July 11, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
> Ever hear of "Amateur" radio...where one does
> something just for the pure joy of it?
Indeed. But this author was proposing a solution to a particular problem. So I recommended an alternative.
If that's 'bomb throwing' you're on the wrong medium.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by KC8VWM on July 11, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
KA4KOE makes an excellent point.
The idea here should be the intelligent exchange of ideas. We need not always agree with the subject matter at hand, however we should respectfully admire those that participate and somehow contribute in a positive way.
It's a dark day when we no longer recognize those that have made contributions, achievements and advancements in our hobby.
73 Charles - KC8VWM
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter
|
|
|
by KA4KOE on July 12, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Perhaps not in this particular article, Marty, but I and others have noticed a disturbing trend. Usually the extremely negative comments start after only a few posts, if for no other reason than to start controversy. If you have read a few of the other articles, you will note that it is usually a certain group who make it their intent to "belch at the dinner table".
Its preferable to say, "I disagree with the author because....(insert reasoned, thoughtful, polite rebuttal)", rather than, "the author is an idiot with a particular axe to grind and should be put in an asylum, etc., etc.,". Perhaps an extreme comparison on my part, I admit, but I hope you get the point.
BTW, Congrats on your WAS award that was featured in QST a few months back. Watch for an article by me coming up hopefully not too long from now.
Regards and my best 73 to the assembled group.
PHILIP
KA4KOE
|
|   |
|
Portable Shelter/NVIS.
|
|
|
by NT4XT on July 14, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
WA2JJH makes actually, an excellent point.
The structure will probably load with a coupler. Like from Harris. Reasonable power to limit RF exposure. It's not like you'd be broadcasting with it anyway, transmissions would be sporadic randomly scheduled and as needed.
On the battle field where RF DFing your coordinates is a concern of life and death magnitude, this could truly be something to consider-
In the real world.
Once again, leave it to Amateurs to come up with some real good ones. This is why NVIS is used by ground troops, Vertical Incidence, real tuff to triangulate a position when the signal comes straight down from the sky.
So after a few field trials, it may well be possible to have shelter and NVIS radiator in one fell swoop.
Great thinking, man. See there? Way tuh go. The concept works.
|
|   |
|
RE: Portable Shelter/NVIS.
|
|
|
by KE2IV on July 14, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
I think this concept is great and the execution first rate.
My question is simply this: What kind of emergency would require this kind of elaborate set up?
Usually, emergencies are either fast-breaking events (think of earthquakes or terrorist bombings) or relatively predictable catastrophes (think of hurricanes and blizzards).
With the first type of emergency - there is no time to set up this elaborate geodisic dome beforehand. With the latter type of emergency - there is sufficient time to establish more secure communications/survival quarters. [Actually, with the latter type of emergency - I do not think I would want to be sitting in a tarp-covered geodisic dome -- would you?).
|
|   |
|
Formatting of article!
|
|
|
by N1YRK on July 22, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
This article is messed up - I have to scroll over to read it. You must have turned line wrapping off in html somehow. Doesn't anyone else have this problem? Or is this a mozilla specific issue and most people here are using MSIE?
|
|   |
|
Fuller dome
|
|
|
by N1YRK on July 22, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Well, it turns out the article looks okay in MSIE. The problem is that super-long URL you posted. I would suggest to the eham editors that they test the web site with several browers. That's the way professionals do it.
About domes: A sphere has the maximum volume per surface area of any shape. This means less material has to be used. Great for storage, but human conditions prefer other shapes, i.e. the traditional recangle. A high ceiling in the middle is a nice touch, gives an airy feeling, but isn't really great for usable space. The low edges towards the ground are suitable for storage and sleeping space, but you can't stand in them. These factors constrain the usefulness of the structure, and is something the dome has in common with the A-frame.
Another problem is that furniture and equipment tends to be rectangle rather than curved, so even more space is wasted in trying to fit in long equipment near the walls. Desks are you going have a space behind them that is wasted. The larger the diameter of the dome, however, the less curve there is per foot at the walls, so the problem is minimized. But a larger dome only exacerbates the problem of uneven headroom. However, there are two types of domes that can be used, one that is less than half of a sphere and one that is greater than half a sphere. The greater than half sphere design will have less of an uneven headroom problem. The disadvantage to this design is that it is less strong, and in fact any wind will tend to try to uproot it, whereas with the less than half sphere design, wind will try to push it down, which is better.
Whichever of these is chosen, it's important that the joining of the members be uniform. That is, make sure that the angles of the bends where the members are screwed together is uniform, and make sure that the members are all perfectly straight and of the same length. Failure to do this can cause unexpected catastrophic failure.
To those who say "well, I can just buy a tent for less money" -- well, that may be true. But this is a 'homebrew' article, which maybe should have said something towards the effect of "if your time isn't expensive, this is a good project". It's a hobby, after all.
Other geodesic design use "hubs" that the members attach to, in order to keep them all at the proper angle. The strength and design of these hubs is important. I've got a few ideas on ways to make inexpensive, light, homebrew plasic hubs, for use with plastic tubing. One of these days I'll get around to trying it out, and if successful, maybe an article will come out of it. Right now, though, I live in the city and there's no room for playing with structures!
|
|   |
|
Email Subscription
You are not subscribed to discussions on this article.
Subscribe!
My Subscriptions
Subscriptions Help
Related News & Articles
How to Help in an Emergency...Tools
Other How To Articles
Measuring a Solid-State PA’s Zs
How to Help in an Emergency...Tools
6-Meter Square Copper Dipole
|
|
|