ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony on Hams' Katrina Response:
from
The ARRL Letter, Vol 24, No 36
on
September 16, 2005
Website:
http://www.arrl.org/
View comments about this article!
ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony on Hams' Katrina Response:
ARRL President Jim Haynie, W5JBP, has provided written testimony on Amateur
Radio's response in the Hurricane Katrina disaster to the US House
Government Reform Committee. Haynie submitted the testimony to the
congressional panel September 15 "on the successful efforts of Amateur Radio
operators providing communications for first responders, disaster relief
agencies and countless individuals in connection with the Hurricane Katrina
relief effort" on behalf of the League.
"As has been proven consistently and repeatedly in the past, when
communications systems fail due to a wide-area or localized natural
disaster, Amateur Radio works, right away, all the time," Haynie's statement
said. "This report is not, therefore, a statement of concern about what must
be changed or improved. It is, rather, a report on what is going right, and
what works, in emergency communications in the Gulf Coast and what can be
depended on to work the next time there is a natural disaster, and the times
after that."
The congressional committee, chaired by Virginia Republican Tom Davis, is
holding hearings on the Hurricane Katrina response. Haynie told the panel
that upward of 1000 Amateur Radio volunteers were or have been serving in
the stricken area to provide communication for served agencies such as the
American Red Cross and The Salvation Army and to facilitate interoperability
among agencies.
"Trained volunteer Amateur Radio operators are also providing
health-and-welfare communications from within the affected area to the rest
of the United States and the world," Haynie said. "In the past week, the
Coast Guard, the Red Cross, and the Federal Emergency Management Agency all
put out calls for volunteer Amateur Radio operators to provide
communications, because phone lines and cell sites were inoperative, and
public safety communications facilities were overwhelmed due to loss of
repeater towers and the large number of first responders in the area."
Haynie pointed out that the main reason Amateur Radio works when other
communication systems fail during natural disasters is that it's not
infrastructure-dependent and is decentralized. "Amateurs are trained in
emergency communications. They are disciplined operators, and their stations
are, in general, portable and reliable," he told the panel.
The ARRL President also put in a good word for the FCC's Enforcement Bureau
for what he called "its efficient and successful efforts" during the
hurricane response in monitoring HF nets to minimize incidents of
interference.
"The Committee should be aware that this vast volunteer resource is always
at the disposal of the federal government," Haynie concluded. "The United
States absolutely can rely on the Amateur Radio Service. Amateur Radio
provides immediate, high-quality communications that work every time, when
all else fails."
Haynie's complete testimony is available on the ARRL Web site
http://www.arrl.org/news/stories/2005/09/15/100/#statement
Source:
The ARRL Letter
Vol. 24, No. 36
September 16, 2005
This article has expired. No more comments may be added.
|
ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony on
|
|
|
by KD4AC on September 16, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
That's nice. Doesn't mean much. When, I mean, IF another CC&R bill is introduced, all this testimony won't do a thing to help get sponsorship.
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by W1RFI on September 18, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
> Its funny -- the hams that were actually in the
> middle of all of this tells a totally different
> story then ARRL --
Can you tell us where we can read these first-hand reports?
Ed Hare, W1RFI
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by K4RAF on September 19, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
http://www.eham.net/articles/12040 is a start to dispelling the myths as portrayed by the League of All Happy Faces, ALL the time.
Instead of producing a radio spot touting the value of our skills & service, they instead produced a feckless spot touting the ARRL itself.
Shameless self-promotion, in a real time of need...
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by W1RFI on September 19, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
A number of other first-hand reports are cited:
http://www.arrl.org/news/stories/2005/09/16/100/?nc=1
Ed
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by W1RFI on September 19, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
> Ham radio operators are helpful NOT BECAUSE ARRL
> TRAINED THEM IN EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS, but rather
> because they can move equipment and get it on the
> air with amazing flexibillity. NOT BECAUSE ARRL has
> trained them.
I agree; hams have been helpful long before ARRL's EMComm courses.
I believe, however, that having training and consistent operating techniques adds to the value and effectiveness of those volunteering their time. The scope of Amateur Radio's response to Katrina is pretty impressive, wouldn't you say? It is far more organized and systematic than I remember from years past.
Ed Hare, W1RFI
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by W9WHE-II on September 19, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Ed Hare, paid ARRL spokeman writes:
"I agree; hams have been helpful long before ARRL's EMComm courses. I believe, however, that having training and consistent operating techniques adds to the value and effectiveness of those volunteering their time. The scope of Amateur Radio's response to Katrina is pretty impressive, wouldn't you say? It is far more organized and systematic than I remember from years past"
Ed:
How about you just give credit to the individual hams? How about you give credit to their selflessness? How about you give credit to someone, ANYONE other then ARRL?
I know of Two constants in the universe:
1) Wherever there is ANY credit to be had, ARRL will attempt to claim it, regardless of whether ARRL earned it; and
2) Whenever there is $$$ to be had, ARRL will be there, holding out its hand.
W9WHE
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by W1RFI on September 20, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
> Ed Hare, paid ARRL spokeman writes:
Tsk, tsk, tsk. When you wrote to Dave Sumner to complain that I was insulting you in my posts here, didn't he explain the same thing that I have explained to you again and again here -- that I post here because I darn well please, speaking only for myself?
I would think that you will someday understand, but you don't want to understand, do you? Again and again you take whatever position you think helps you in your clearcut goal of interpreting everything that ARRL says and does in the most unflattering light.
Ed Hare, W1RFI
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by W1RFI on September 20, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
ARRL basher W9WHE-2 writes (hey, I am sure you won't mind if I flatter you by copying your "style," right?):
> How about you just give credit to the individual
> hams? How about you give credit to their
> selflessness? How about you give credit to someone,
> ANYONE other then ARRL?
What ARE you talking about, WHE? The stories I read on the ARRL web and in QST again and again talk about the work of individual hams involved in EmComm. ARRL also does promote itself, but if ARRL were NOT telling hams about ARRL, you would lead the howls of protest that it is being secretive. Oh, wait, didn't you do that in an earlier post somewhere? :-)
Do you really see the world this way, or is is part of the bash? It is very sad to see you act this way. There is no doubt that no matter what is posted about ARRL, you will look for an interpretation that lets you stand on your soapbox and treat the rest of the folks here as if only you can see the TRVTH and they should be glad that you are here to show them the way.
This is just like the lawyer in court who offers the interpretation that supports the side that he or she represents. Oh, wait... now I understand! :-)
Ed Hare, W1RFI
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by W1RFI on September 20, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
W9WHE-II wrote: (say, whatever happened to W9WHE #1?):
> Wherever there is ANY credit to be had, ARRL will
> attempt to claim it, regardless of whether ARRL
> earned it.
In the articles you are bashing, can you point to anything specific that ARRL has claimed credit for doing that it didn't do?
I am curious as to why you said what you said? Some specific examples will help. In the ARRL articles I know about, the League actually did what it said it did. Do you think that everything ARRL says it did didn't actually happen?
Something more than hand-waving cheap shots would be useful to the discussion, WHE...
Ed
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by W6EM on September 20, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
W1RFI says:
"Something more than hand-waving cheap shots would be useful to the discussion, WHE..."
Hi, Ed. Our Esquirian Troll is at it again, I see.
I found the statement in support of Amateur Radio by Motorola in the Government Reform testimony quite refreshing. Thank goodness you guys found a more credible source to offer Motorola's opinion of amateur radio than did the reporter from the Wall Street Journal. :-)
Lee
W6EM
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by KC8VWM on September 21, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"The scope of Amateur Radio's response to Katrina is pretty impressive, wouldn't you say?"
---------------------------
...Absolutely !!
Actually, I have to say that our good friend Jimbo has pretty good timing in shamelessly self promoting Amateur Radio (as one user post suggests) to members of Congress during the aftermath of Katrina.
What I find especially interesting is that some people that have complained that the ARRL was not doing enough to promote amateur radio in the past, are now the same people accusing the ARRL for promoting amateur radio shamelessly... ???
...What gives anyways?
Awareness campaigns like this serve to enhance how Amateur Radio as an entity is viewed and respected by both government agencies and the general public.
Keep up the great job and I think this sort of PR is always something positive and is in the interests and right direction for the future of Amateur Radio.
Bravo! Excellent timing!
My Best 73
|
|   |
|
RE: ARRL President Submits Congressional Testimony
|
|
|
by K4RAF on September 26, 2005
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"...now the same people accusing the ARRL for promoting amateur radio shamelessly... ???"
No, just promoting themselves & not amateur radio. Sending people to their website (i.e. the recent hurricane PSA), where the answers to their questions are there, but ONLY for sale. This clearly shows the ARRL is Feckless...
|
|   |
|
Email Subscription
You are not subscribed to discussions on this article.
Subscribe!
My Subscriptions
Subscriptions Help
Related News & Articles
Holders of Expired Novice, Tech Licenses Eligible
IARU Represents Hams at WRC-2000
FCC Feeling Restructuring's Impact
Lew McCoy, W1ICP, SK (updated)
Is 'Nothing' Better?
Other News Articles
Cuba Facilitates Equipment to Amateur Radio Operators:
ARNewsline # 1684 -- Nov. 20 2009:
Propagation Forecast Bulletin #47 de K7RA:
Technology Enthusiast Boosts Skills with Amateur Radio:
Solar Radio Flux: Slow Upward Trend Since Summer:
|