Lightning Safety
from
Larry Kendall, K5END
on
June 14, 2009
View comments about this article!
"Editor's Note: Due to the popularity of some of eHam's older articles, many of which you may not have read, the eHam.net team has decided to rerun some of the best articles that we have received since eHam's inception. These articles will be reprinted to add to the quality of eHam's content and in a show of appreciation to the authors of these articles."
Lightning Safety
Lightning-human encounters cause burns, trauma and electrical interference with physiological processes, often with fatal results. This article addresses personal safety concerns with lightning. Antenna and grounding practices are covered quite well in recent QST articles as well as ARRL and other literature and are therefore not iterated here. Lightning protection for backpacking and blue-water sailing are not covered comprehensively in this article.
The following three points are important.
Big Point 1: The first strike of lightning in a thunderstorm is just as deadly as the last. For some reason, people tend to dismiss the danger of lightning for at least the first few strikes. Electrical storms don't have to "warm up" to be deadly. If you can hear thunder, you are vulnerable immediately. Seek shelter.
Big Point 2: A tree is a poor choice for shelter. Lightning striking the tree will flashover in a deadly penumbral shape around the tree as it seeks paths to ground. Secondly, the tree sap will boil and turn to steam rapidly, exploding the trunk of the tree. This is a bad place to be when it happens.
Big Point 3: Lightning is second only to floods in terms of "natural" fatalities. Fear lightning more than earthquakes, tornadoes, wildfires or volcanoes. In the United States, Florida has the highest frequency of lightning events; lightning in Alaska is rare.
LIGHTNING BASICS
Lightning is the plasma path that allows charge equalization between the atmosphere and the ground or between regions of the atmosphere. This process is nearly continuous worldwide. The process of lightning path generation as a plasma wave forges its way through the air is both fascinating and esoteric. Air does break down under electric fields and lightning occurs. That is what matters.
A lightning strike is a "current source" and is effectively independent of load impedance. Call it an electrical Tsunami. You can neither stop it nor out run it. Protect yourself as you would from a Tsunami: stay out of its path!
A lightning strike is composed of several strokes as various charged regions are equalized. Stroke "leaders" may originate and extend from cloud to ground, ground to cloud or cloud to cloud. You can observe the individual strokes in the duration of a single strike especially well if at a distance when wind across the ground is significant where the strike occurs. The paths shift slightly with the wind during the series, giving the appearance (to human visual perception) of "ribbon lightning." Strokes often fork into diverse paths as the charge finds the most efficient routes toward equalization.
Yes, Virginia, lightning can strike the ground where the sky overhead is clear and blue; thus the expression, "out of the blue." Lightning can travel horizontally for miles before striking the ground. If you can hear thunder, you are within range of a strike.
Cloud-to-ground voltages range from 100 million to 1 billion Volts.
Typical peak current is 30,000 Amperes. This means that only 0.0000033 of the electrical current in a routine lightning strike is lethal.
Typical length of a lightning path is 5 kilometers.
The short time domain of a lightning stroke means that a large bandwidth is conducted and radiated as energy. This is why lightning static noise is present everywhere across the radio bands. It is less noticeable on FM modes, but it is still there on the bands (lightning is noticeable on FM broadcast mostly as "dead air" when their transmitter/antenna takes a strike!) What does this mean to us? It means that the protective grounding configuration must account for and have minimum impedance for all frequencies from DC to UHF.
Power of a single lightning strike:
Visible light 1-3%
Sound >10%
Heat <50%
Radio waves <50%
Duration ranges from 0.001 to 0.5 seconds.
The region around a ground strike will cause a voltage gradient in the top two feet or so of the soil until the current is dissipated. Persons standing with feet spread or laying on the ground are at increased risk. (Anecdotally, it is claimed that cattle die when the poor heifer's axis is aligned with this gradient. Who knows?)
Shrapnel from objects disintegrating near a ground strike is another common source of injury, especially in rocky areas.
LIGHTNING PROTECTION
The best defense to lightning is to seek safe shelter within an ENCLOSED structure, which means you need to be aware of the weather and have a plan beforehand. For example, any boater who finds himself in peril on a lake when a thunderstorm emerges needs to work on his situational awareness, if not consider another form of recreation. Think ahead and plan. The human species supposedly became more intelligent as a result of the last ice age. Those who were able to plan ahead were the ones who survived!
Buildings which are NOT SAFE are those with exposed openings. These include beach shacks, picnic shelters, pavilions, carports, and baseball dugouts. Porches are especially dangerous.
Once inside a suitable building, stay away from electrical appliances and plumbing fixtures. Lightning can travel great distances through power lines, especially in rural areas. This means a distant storm poses a risk inside your home, especially in the absence of proper grounding. Electrical appliances pose a risk to the user, ESPECIALLY corded telephones. Computers are also dangerous as they usually are connected to an ISP facility and the house AC. It should be obvious this is not the time for a shower, bath or a hot tub party.
An enclosed metal vehicle makes a good shelter. When lightning strikes a metal car, it is conducted through the car's metal structure and then arcs to the ground, at the easiest point and usually from the axle to ground. Aftermarket (ham) antennas may compromise the safety within a vehicle. Roll the windows up (glass is a pretty good inhibitor to plasma) and avoid contact with any conducting paths leading to the outside of the vehicle. Keep in mind that tornadoes often coincide with thunderstorms, and a car is not adequate shelter from a tornado.
Don't fall prey to the urban legend: the myth of tires. The tires have nothing to do with lightning safety. A car is safer because you are surrounded by a conductor, and Gauss's law, #1 in Maxwell's 4 famous collective equations is a good source to find an explanation of why this matters. In short, the voltage drop from the top of the car where the lightning hits to the floorboard where your behind is planted is enough protection to keep the air inside the vehicle from ionizing and providing a path for the lightning. BUT, I wouldn't go raising my hands to the headliner to test the protection factor! The "myth of tires" is pointed out here because of the following unsafe vehicles. Convertible (or fiberglass) vehicles offer little safety from lightning, even if the top is "up". Other vehicles, which are NOT SAFE during lightning storms, are those, which have open cabs, such as golf carts, tractors, and construction equipment. Motorcycles do not offer adequate protection from lightning.
Water or material on the surface of windows may heat with rapid steam generation or flashover conduction and cause the glass to shatter. Be aware of this possibility. This author is not aware of documented examples of this, but includes it as a possibility and recommends facing the interior of the car or building during shelter from an intense electrical storm.
Use the "30/30 rule." If the interval between the light flash and the thunder is less than 30 seconds, seek shelter and remain sheltered for 30 minutes after the last strike of the storm. "Counting seconds" is not an accurate method to estimate lightning distance! The speed of sound is dependent on air density and other factors, and there is no accounting for triangulation. Note that thunder may be a rumble rather than a sharp report. This is because the observer would be hearing various regions of the lightning path, all of which travel varied distances at the speed of sound, which also varies. A sharp thunder report implies the site of the ground strike is nearby, nothing more.
For outdoor activities:
The first outdoor procedure is to get indoors. Recreational pilots have a saying about weather. "It's better to be on the ground wishing you were flying than to be flying and later wish you were on the ground." The same logic applies to lightning. Know the weather forecast before you venture outside.
HAVE A PLAN and make sure the responsible party members understand the plan.
Designate individuals to monitor the weather.
Know safety shelters in advance.
Designate individuals to organize and lead evacuation.
This practice will save softball, little league and soccer players. Better to forfeit the game or skip the practice than to die for no reason at all. If the coach is not compliant, don't let him reduce your life expectancy or that of your child. Write him off to Darwin. Few will remember the outcome of the game for very long. The death will be remembered for much longer.
Golfers, listen up! Think about this. You're standing in wide open spaces, you are the tallest objects in the vicinity, you installed metal electrodes on your shoes (damp leather against your feet) pressed into the damp earth, and you're swinging a pretty fair "lightning rod" (carbon graphite can conduct too!) several feet above your head, if not holding an umbrella constructed with "pointy-ended" (perfect for coronal discharge initiation of a ground leader!) metal ribs extending a couple of feet in all directions. Call it a day, go inside, have a "beverage" and tell war stories (which is probably the important part of the outing anyway. Am I right?)
Backpacking and hiking require special instruction beyond the scope of this article. But in short, get off the ridges, spread the group out and stay away from the trees. Minimize your footprint on the ground; it would be better to squat with feet together, rather than lie flat. The group members should spread out considerably so that a strike would affect fewer members and the other members would still be able to apply first aid and begin medical evacuation.
Bicyclists, head for the nearest shelter or take cover. Stay aware of the weather and have a plan. If thunderstorms are predicted, consider whether you should ride another day.
Remember:
1. Lightning is an everyday killer across most of the United States.
2. The best protection from lightning is to stay out its path by seeking shelter.
3. Become informed and have a plan.
This article has expired. No more comments may be added.
|
Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KB2DHG on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Lightning is an everyday killer across most of the United States.
GEE, I guess the best means of lightning protection is to leave the United States!
Seriously this is a good article... I am sure we all are aware of the potential hazard of electrical storms.
Thanks for your review!
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K0BG on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
There's one strike Larry left out; ground to ground.
Some years ago, I had an opportunity to be at a transmitting site west of Salt Lake City. The site sits on a plateau between two mountain peaks, both taller than the plateau. One lightning path (between the peaks) is through the transmitter building! Albeit well grounded, lightning doesn't seem to care. This was the first, and only time, I've seen ball lightning. The eerie blue glow, and resulting hum is not to be believed! To say it was frightening, would have been an understatement!
Alan, KØBG
www.k0bg.com
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by WA8MEA on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Lightning is an everyday killer across most of the United States.
-------------------------------------------------------
This means we must adopt "LIGHTNING CONTROL"....
This is a SHOCKING topic, to be sure.
It STRIKES at the heart of both hams and non-hams alike....
This article does have its FLASHES of genius, though....
OK....time for me to put a FORK in it....
73, Bill - WA8MEA
PS: Can anyone at all tell me why some Old Timers put their PL-259's in glass jars after disconnecting their antennae????
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KC8VWM on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
PS: Can anyone at all tell me why some Old Timers put their PL-259's in glass jars after disconnecting their antennae????
--------
A jar is a good way to store all the inbound QSO's the antenna picks up for a later time.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by NI0C on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"Can anyone at all tell me why some Old Timers put their PL-259's in glass jars after disconnecting their antennae????"
I guess they want to get themselves in a pickle.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K1CJS on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
The jar idea came from old timers who just wanted to avoid the static electric charge from jumping to anything coming near the tip of the connector and getting a small charge. Guess they figure it would jump to the shield first.
Agreed that it would do no good if the antenna system were actually hit by a direct strike.
Its nice to see e-ham taking this problem seriously and re-running this article. Good job--for once.
|
|   |
|
Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KC0RBX on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"Can anyone at all tell me why some Old Timers put their PL-259's in glass jars after disconnecting their antennae????"
It's where they also keep their false teeth. They're hoping a lightning strike will clean their falsies giving them a "bright" smile!
|
|   |
|
Personal Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by AI2IA on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
This article should have been called "Personal Lightning Safety." The author gives the reasons:
"This article addresses personal safety concerns with lightning. Antenna and grounding practices are covered quite well in recent QST articles as well as ARRL and other literature and are therefore not iterated here. Lightning protection for backpacking and blue-water sailing are not covered comprehensively in this article."
As is so typical of eHam.net, the posters will now twist this topic upside down and inside out until the thread peters out with wisecracks.
If it does nothing more than remind readers to avoid outdoor activity in thunderstorm weather and to have a plan to get out of it if the possibilities look like a good day, then it will have served some good purpose.
Equipment lightning safety is a topic impossible to discuss reasonably on eHam.net.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by W4VR on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
What if I have a metal roof on my house...will that make safer...similar to a car?
|
|   |
|
Lightning Safety - Not concerned? Look Here!
|
|
|
by KI4NVK on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
A timely article. Here is a new video that all Hams should view. Last night Jim Bailey of East Palatka, Florida found out the dangers of a Lightning Strike. Jim had a bird feeder strung up in the tree in his front yard, and happened to be video taping when it hit the chain on the tree.
This is a good reminder to all Hams out there. Disconnect before the storm hits, and be safe. Jim's chain wasn't near as attractive to a strike as YOUR antenna's are!
http://www.firstcoastnews.com/news/local/news-article.aspx?storyid=139798&provider=rss
vr,
David Grimes
KI4NVK
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Alan,
What you witnessed was very rare. You're fortunate to have seen it. I'd catalog that in the "memory scrapbook."
What I call a "memory scrapbook" is the collection of rarest of events, personally witnessed.
The centerpiece of mine is the zodiacal light I observed with the naked eye in November 1985, and recall it like it was last night.
I was observing the early stages of Halley's comet in the constellation Taurus, and further West along the ecliptic there was the zodiacal light, all the way down to the horizon. I'll remember it much longer than I will having observed the comet.
|
|   |
|
RE: Personal Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K7BAB on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
I was living in the high desert of Central Nevada when this incident happened.
There were very few thunder storms, but we did have something people called “heat lightning.” Out of a sky with few clouds, a flash would be seen and a thunderclap heard.
A teenager was standing somewhere in town and was struck by lightning and killed. No rain, no clouds to speak of.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by WA8MEA on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
>>"Can anyone at all tell me why some Old Timers put their PL-259's in glass jars after disconnecting their antennae????"
>I guess they want to get themselves in a pickle.
Goodness! Gracious! Great balls of fire!!
Bill
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by WA8MEA on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
A teenager was standing somewhere in town and was struck by lightning and killed. No rain, no clouds to speak of.
----------------------------------------------------
On a more serious note, this is where the phrase "out of the clear, blue sky" comes from.
There are scientific disagreements on this phenomena. Some meteorologists claim that blue sky might have been overhead, but dark skies were off in another direction.
Others claim it is the result of winds and low humidity causing static build-up to the point of discharge.
However, there seems to be enough documented cases that show that lightning can/will "come out of the clear, blue sky."
Now excuse me while I go spontaneously combust....
Bill
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by QRZDXR2 on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Good article..
Arizona State has done lots of studies on lightening and safety. Their bottom line.. GOOD LUCK.
As any static charge develops you just can't predict all the discharge points.
We know that a sharp object pointing skyward and above all the other items will normally be the discharge point.
As to being safe in a car.. what makes you think that 6 or 8 inches of wet rubber tires is going to keep you safe after all the bolt just came through how many feet of dry/wet air and you think them little tires are going to save you? Faraday showed that enclosing yourself in a metal cage would keep you safe. Well Arizona state put that one to bed when the bolt jumped from the top of the cage to the ground plate in the bottom. Guess the steel was not put togeather as good as the copper cage that Faraday used.
But some protection is better than none if you build the system.
A Faraday Cage Lightning Protection System consists of Strike Termination Devices (air terminals) along the ridges, flat-roof portions and perimeters, interconnected with specialized lightning protection conductor coursed throughout the building, terminating at grounding locations.
The air terminals are spaced out at 20'-25' intervals around the perimeter and peaked ridges of structures and 50' intervals across mid-roof areas. The specialized conductors consist of many small gauge wires interwoven in a rope braid to maximize the surface area.
Each 100' of perimeter requires a downlead. A downlead is a cable connecting the roof-top lightning protection to a grounding location. The grounding location is typically a ground rod or a series of ground rods, but it can also be a ground plate. The grounding system can also include a counterpoise, which is basically a buried ground wire that interconnects all grounding locations and helps to make all grounding systems common.
Now whay the many small guage wires interwoven into a rope braid... Well as some now know lighting is not just a single DC discharge. Instead the new research has proven it is a HIGH FREQUENCY AC DISCHARGE. Thus like our UHF microwave stuff it only is conserned with the surface conduction. (which now is well known and accepted)
So when you see that lightening bolt your really seeing a rapid charge/discharge osc taking place.
Alen...
I too have seen the ball lightening run across the the ground... going from blue to a yellow.. it moves in strange ways. Most things it doesn't come in contact with due to the repulsion charges but indeed it will kill any living thing that gets in its way as we saw with the ground hogs. Getting a picture of it is difficult. I tried to get several and they never turned out on the film. Just a white blotch.
how they form is interesting. Mostly right after a ligtening bolt hits. They only last for about 5-20 seconds.. and float around like a beach ball on invisable water surface. \
The research contenues as now the guys in spacelab are saying a shaft or plumes shoots up from the cloud as the lightening discharges. could there be more to this than meets the eye. Do sunspots promote lightening? Where do the charges come from... if they are all like charges then why doesn't the cloud repell and disapate. We know air movement and friction can develop static charges. What conditions are ripe for it to happen. Why doesn't it happen to other clouds than the Q's ? What is so special about them than others?
And now the experts tell us that if you have a ham antenna up, its better to leave it un-grounded than to ground it so as to remain somewhat uniform with the charge around it. Grounding it could upset the field and actually cause the lightening to emulate from your antenna. anything pointie concentrates the charge-discharge point due to the potential/air breakdown densenty. Remember its surface charge we dealing with here. (think of the surface charge as a drop of oil in a glass jar of water.. its always moving around. But, why doesn't it (the charge) disapate. Tulsa was the expert here. To find out why you need to read his works. Thus we have the cloud which has potential to itself or the ground. We have ground which has potential to the cloud and itself (as allen has said) and we have the density of the charge with repect to the clouds size and distance from the ground. All of these combinations have unlimited variances that one has to contend with to be safe and not a number in the dead zone. (by the way you can get lightening on a clear day with the wind blowing too... makes surface charge like skuffing across the carpet and then touching the door knob.)
Oh and never stick you finger up in the air to give mother nature the international peace sign when its stroming above you... one documented case showed that happened. Blew the guys finger away.. but he lived to tell about it.
Another documented case was a ranger rick who has been hit at least 3 times by lightening ... setting in his truck...
And of course you always get some from the gene pool that want to go outside and get a closer look at the storm. Lucky those sometime become statics and keep the rest safe from sudden death.
Most interesting article... thanks for stemulating the hams who have lots of wire things up in the air too.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by QRZDXR2 on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
By the way lightening does have a resonace frequency. Somewhere around 3.5 mc so they are saying... gee right in the 80 mtr ham band where the nut hang out. go figure
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KL7EDK on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Check this web site in the evenings during the summer months. We get a few good storms...certainly nothing like the folks in Florida.
http://afsmaps.blm.gov/imf/imf.jsp?site=lightning
Jerry
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
KL7EDK,
Yes, Alaska gets lightning, but in comparison to the lower 48 the incidence is what I call "rare" in terms of strikes, per square mile, per year.
In fact, I understand, lightning causes the lion's share of the forest fires in Alaska.
Long before the other 49 states even knew who she is, Sarah Palin was pointing out the hazards and consequences of lightning in Alaska.
When my family lived in Alaska, in Anchorage and along the Kuskokwim, we hardly ever saw lightning. I personally don't recall ever once seeing lighting in Alaska. But it does happen. We had a bear in our front yard who wanted to come inside the house, but never had lightning visit us.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
>
"Somewhere around 3.5 mc"
Close.
That figure is close to what they call the "plasma frequency" of the ionosphere. Anything below that frequency will always be reflected back, even in the lowest solar activity.
So that component of the lightning signature will always be "reflected" back down to the surface (the ionosphere is much, much, much higher in altitude than the lightning activity.)
Anything higher than the plasma frequency happens to be in conditions at the time will either pass on through to outer space or will be "refracted" back to the surface where your antenna sits.
But that reflection/refraction of the ionosphere layers is an article for another day.
|
|   |
|
Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by WA1RNE on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"Big Point 3: Lightning is second only to floods in terms of "natural" fatalities. Fear lightning more than earthquakes, tornadoes, wildfires or volcanoes. In the United States, Florida has the highest frequency of lightning events; lightning in Alaska is rare."
>>> I was in New Orleans many years ago and witnessed some of the most intense lightning I have ever seen.
Most of the strikes appeared to run straigth from cloud to ground and appeared to be miles in length.
Gave me an eerie feeling sitting in the middle of Interstate 10 with almost a foot of water all around us in some parts of the highway. Luckily we were riding in a good size 4x4 pickup otherwise we would be underwater like some folks were.
...WA1RNE
|
|   |
|
Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KB1NXL on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Well, my personal story involves proving Faraday and the skin effect correct. While driving back from a hamfest at MIT in Cambridge, MA, last July 20th, I was caught in a massive thunderstorm and torrential rain. I, being a ham, knew of the very real dangers of lightning. I decided to wait it out and sit in my car, knowing that, windows up, I would be safe. Or so I thought. As the storm eventually past the Cambridge area, I started my trek home. As I travelled the route, the clouds darkened and it began to rain in bunches - apparently I managed to follow the storm, or it followed me. As it was, I slowed my car to avoid hydroplaning - going a max of 35 mph. With 2m radio on, listening to the weather alert tone scream and a severe thunderstorm warning blurt from the speaker, I attempted to immediately turn my rig off. Too late! The bolt hit within 3 seconds of the alert and immediately my rear window exploded into a bazillion shards of glass. As I recovered from the immense blast of light/sound/shock of the event, I noticed I was not moving. My car's computers (all of them) told me of their death by announcing via the odometer "NO CMPTR". I exited the car to investigate, noticing that apparently my 2m antenna was vaporized into oblivion. a burn hole was noticed at the entrance to my coax, but as was told in another reply, the lightning chose a better path to ground than entering the cabin-lucky me! Suffice to say I survived with intimate knowledge of Faraday's law and the Skin effect. Thank goodness lightning is a AC event and not DC and will go to ground with the least resistance path!! I am driving now with a new (used) car, complete with ham radio installed (IC-7000) and two antennas (HF hamstick and Diamond VHF/UHF). The HF 'lightning rod' hamstick has a (very) quick disconnect and ANY hint of thunder the antennas come off immediately-i'm not going to prove the saying wrong that lightning never strikes twice in the same place (or person).
73
Rick
KB1NXL
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Even the author has a personal story, that perhaps inspired the interest in lightning.
Many years ago I was mowing and trying to hurry up to finish the lawn before the rain started.
Dumb. Beyond dumb, really.
The lawnmower died suddenly. I tried to start it. Nothing.
So I took it inside the garage to check it out. I got as far as removing the engine head and discovered the burnt valve. No compression. That explains it. The lawn won't get finished that day.
About that time I heard the lightning strike a small Fruitless Mulberry tree in the front yard, at about the location I would have been mowing had the lawnmower not died so abruptly.
It was the proverbial "first strike" of the storm, just as deadly as any other strike during the storm.
I figured I had been more lucky than smart, and began to take lightning very seriously from that point onward.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Thanks, Terry
I submitted one on our Dayton trip with a sort of unusual perspective.
Assuming it gets posted, it will be interesting to see how it goes over.
<getting flame-proof suit out, haha>
LK
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by N4JTE on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
RR Larry, Tnx for reminders on lightning safety, but there ain't no flamesuit gonna protect any article writer on this venue, tough crowd, take care.
Bob
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Yeah, thanks Bob I noticed.
I figure I have a lot of karma to burn off and will let them do it for me.
:)
LK
|
|   |
|
Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by W3LZK on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
From my own personal experience, I have a cousin who has been struck not once but twice. No, it wasn't a direct strike, although, the first time may have been. Anyway, a good friend of mine who lives a few miles south of me is a lightening strike survivor. I also knew another gentleman here in town who is a lightening strike survivor, both my friends and my cousin, have major lingering problems.
On another occasion, at the local ball field here a couple years ago, there was the bolt from the blue and one of the local school coaches was struck and killed. So yea, you can never be too careful when it comes to personal protection from lightening.
Mark
W3LZK
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K9KJM on June 14, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Very good article!
The U.S.A. is far from the lightning "capitol" of the world. Rwanda Africa has that title, With almost 2 1/2 times the amount of thunderstorms that Florida has! Many other places like India have more lightning than we do.
More tidbits: A lightning bolt has up to 300 million volts, Average of 30,000 amps (Ranges from about 10,000 to 200,000 amps) (Good thing they are such short duration or no known conductor could handle the current!)
The earth has about 2,000 thunderstorms going on at any given time.
The earth receives 10 million tons of nitrogen from lightning each year.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K1CJS on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"Thank goodness lightning is a AC event and not DC and will go to ground with the least resistance path!"
Lightning is an AC event?? I don't think so!
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by W2LJ on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
About 10 years ago during Field Day, we had a bad thunderstorm blow through. We disconnected the antennas from the rigs and tossed them outside our pop up camper ..... except for one (which we forgot) - we had left it laying on the floor. We were sitting there and every now and then, we would heard a small snapping sound. We looked down and would see a small blue arc jump from the center conductor to the shield of the coax connector. I guess that's why Old Timers were putting their PL-259s in glass jars.
|
|   |
|
Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by WB4LFC on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Good article!!
Even though this is not about radio it is a good safety article. After 40 years of being an electrical engineer and ham, I have found the best way for me to protect my eguipment is to unplug and isolate everything.Seems like a lot of trouble,but I have lost anything yet to lightning.
I live next to a golf course and I am amazed at the people I see that will continue play in a thunder storm.I guess they can't afford to loose the green fee.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by W8JN on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
larry, no controversy here hihi. great article!
73 paul w8jn
|
|   |
|
Purpose of article
|
|
|
by K5END on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
>
All content is original, but thanks for the compliment.
Last year two men were killed instantly when they were installing an antenna for Amateur Radio use and inadvertently contacted an overhead power line.
In light of that tragedy, an article was written for eham readers to emphasize power line safety and how important it is to remember the danger when working with antennas and/or guy lines around overhead power lines.
In the comments following the power line article, the desire for a similar article on lightning safety was made known.
In response came the lightning safety article, which is relevant to Amateur Radio during Field Day, Amateur/mobile, installing antennas in inclement weather, and so on.
In general I think we all agree that we want to keep our fellow Hams alive.
|
|   |
|
Lightning safety
|
|
|
by KB3IKW on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
I was in the electric (plasma?) field of a lighting strike, a football field away from the bolt, which was from cloud to ground. I was holding an umbrella, walking my dog, when I felt the jolt shock the umbrella out of my hand, and my dog was knocked to the ground. Although I was not knocked down, I was dazed for a moment, and then I realized that I was about 40 yards from shelter in the middle of a field, feeling very vulnerable.
My dog and I ran to the closest shelter, the hotel where we were staying. I knocked on the door, my wife opened the door, looked at me and said,
"You look like you were struck by lightning."
She may not always be right, but I have learned she is never wrong.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
It's hard to speculate, but if you were 100 yards from the location of the ground leader, and there were only one ground leader you **may** have experienced the difference of ground potential between your feet.
If so, depending on whether you were facing the strike or facing perpendicular to it you or your dog got the worst of it.
"They" say this is more dangerous to cattle and horses because of the distance between their front and back feet, if they happen to be facing toward the strike or facing 180 degrees away from the strike.
I honestly can't say for sure how true this is in reality. It would be a good research topic.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning safety
|
|
|
by K6AER on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Larry,
Lightining kills more people than floods in the US by a large margin.
Nice artical.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by AJ4MJ on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
Yes, my Boy Scout handbook was chock full of golfing advice :P
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K6AKR on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Articles on lightning safety and protection always grab my interest. My experience is that hams along the coast in Northern California do not take lightning safety and protection as seriously as others due to the relatively low number of t-storms we have. That said it only takes one strike to cause havoc. I have taken a number of steps to mitigate the effects of a strike at my QTH. What I think is missing in much of the literature on lightning protection is the real world experience of amateur radio stations and commercial interests that have taken lightning strikes. What protection/mitigation steps were taken, what happened, what worked, what didn't?
73,
Art
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by MACKAY3031 on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
WA8MEA: Regarding the glass jar...in college I had a 120 foot antenna up 80 feet.When storms got close or there was blowing snow it would arc rhythmically across the 1/4 safety gap.My friend in the other dorm had a 300 foot wire up.It made 2 inch sparks.So he stuck the lead into a peanut butter jar!I rigged a gap for him that was 1/4 inch and at times it discharged so fast it was nearly continuous.His lead in before we put a spark gap to ground was scary.The glass jar just prevents the hv from nuking nearby stuff or charging up the operating position!
Neither installation was safe in the event of a direct strike.My current system is, but at college, installing a ground field was out of the question.We were both pretty lucky...and a bit irresponsible.But reception was just fantastic with that 120 footer on the SP-600.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 15, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
>
Nowadays the glass jar has a different purpose.
It allows the OM to continue operating at the station during extended contesting without having to take a break every 20 minutes.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KG4TKC on June 16, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Glad to see this article run again. I enjoyed it the first time it ran. I always felt that lightning was something that a member of the ARS needed to have a good knowledge of,and a good plan for,so I was surprised to see the comments that this 'was not ham radio'. Oh,well,to each his own,,:)
I did learn something new from this article being run again. I learned that the author is a gentleman and a scholar from the way he handled the would-be trolls. That in itself was a delight to see.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by W9WHE-II on June 16, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
All these lightning strikes are the result of global warming.
NOW, if only we could get the high preist of the global warming religion to shrink his own massive carbon footprint, these life threatening lightning strikes would subside. But alas....$98 million in global warming profits in 8 years, is a HUGE insentive for reverend Al Gore. Perhaps reverend Al would do it for the children and minorities, who are hardest hit by his selfishness.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KA2UUP on June 16, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Gee, in Massachusetts today, as I write this, it is 60 degrees outside. I am waiting for the Global Warming to finally show up. However, I prefer it this way, no Global Warming=no lightning! Life is great when I don't have to disconnect my antennas!
BTW, thanks for the good article!
Regards from Bert @ KA2UUP
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 16, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
>
"I learned that the author is a gentleman and a scholar"
Thanks, but I must confess I only behave myself on good days, hihi. One won't have to look too far in the forum to see comments I now wish I had not posted. But, I keep trying.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by NA7I on June 16, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"Can anyone at all tell me why some Old Timers put their PL-259's in glass jars after disconnecting their antennae?"
Well, some are so old they remember Ben Franklin.
(But, how can you trust somebody who did what he did???)
|
|   |
|
Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KA4DQJ on June 16, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Lightning will sure take your equipment. Last Spring I was at home when I heard what sounded like a pistol shot in my radio shack, coinciding with a very near lightning strike.
Everything in the shack save one old IC-730 was fried... tranceivers, receivers amplifiers...if it was on the table shelves, it was fried. All antennas had been disconnected, but the strike came through the electrical line. Although the home circuit breaker was thrown, the surge destroyed my surge protector, as well as all the equipment power line fuses. Although the strike was on the lines, it also went through the cases... it actually arc'd through the equipment cases as it jumped from one piece of gear to the other, leaving burned spots to mark its progress.
The sharp crack I heard was the electrolytic capacitors exploding like mini-grenades. The caps actually had enough force to cause secondary damage to components... even if that was necessary.
Why the old IC-730 survived, I can't say othe than perhaps Lord Lightning decided it wasn't worth destroying! :) I replaced a blown DC powerline fuse on the thing and found it was otherwise unharmed.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 16, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
DQJ,
Were the chassis for the AC input amplifiers/radios grounded locally in the shack, other than the AC Neutral and AC Ground?
Does the DC power supply have a ground lug and if so is it grounded in the shack?
And, if so, is that shack ground or ground rod also bonded to your house electrical ground?
Just curious. Even lightning damage is fascinating to me.
TNX,
Larry
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KI4SDY on June 17, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
K5END said; "All content is original, but thanks for the compliment."
I am very interested as to how you came to the conclusion of the following facts, and other technical information, in your "article" on lightning:
"Cloud to ground voltages range from 100 million to 100 billion volts."
"Typical length of a lightning path is 5 kilometers."
Please supply the mathematical equations and the physics theory you created for this "original" information or if you physically measured it, tell us how you accomplished that feat!
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KI4SDY on June 17, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Correction, you stated; Cloud to ground voltages range from 100 million to 1 billion volts." I wouldn't want to misquote your "original" information!
Now, how about the mathematical equations and physics theory you used to "create" this article?
|
|   |
|
Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by NZ4O on June 17, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
WHAT??? Are you saying that placing the end of your coax in a glass jar does not protect the radio shack equipment and operator from lightning damage and/or death???
My Very Close Encounters With Florida Lightning Bolts:
http://www.kn4lf.com/kn4lf1.htm
73 & GUD DX,
Thomas F. Giella, NZ4O
Lakeland Fl, USA
http://www.nz4o.com
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by WB0MCO on June 17, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"Can anyone at all tell me why some Old Timers put their PL-259's in glass jars after disconnecting their antennae?"
You all have it wrong,just can't be any old glass jar.
It has to be a green Mason Jar and has to have mothballs in the jar. I seen this first hand years
ago in the shack of a now silent key that really believed it worked. Every time a storm passes by I think about him, and can still recall the smell of
those mothballs.
Nice article!
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 17, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
>
"It has to be a green Mason Jar"
Wouldn't Kerr jars work?
I hear tell of Mason jars, but all I ever see are Kerr jars.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KA4DQJ on June 17, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Hi Larry,
I didn't have any special grounding inside the shack... just the AC ground. The DC power supply did have a ground lug, and was only grounded via the AC ground. The two power supplies, a 35A and 20A running various equipment were not damaged and are still in use today.
I've been hamming for 31 years, and have always taken care to disconnect all antennas when not in use. Maybe I'm just a dummy, but I never considered a lightning strike to come from the opposite direction... the AC power apparatus. Also, I put too much faith in the surge protector. The circuit breaker was tripped, and the surge protector destroyed in the strike along with all the gear. An old antenna tuner was unharmed, as was an old MFJ CW audio filter. The 2m and HF gear was all blasted except the old IC-730.
There was no smoke, no smell afterwards, and nothing was hot to the touch. The "bang" I heard in the shack coincided perfectly with the lightning/thunder. I don't remember any time lag at all between the flash and the bang so the strike was apparently right on top of my house. I walked around the house and property and never located the site of the strike.
The antennas, an elevated BTV vertical, and an NVIS were unharmed. No trees, poles or any other place on the house showed evidence of a strike. It was odd how some things were spared, and others (most of everything) was wiped out. I didn't even get spare parts out of the deal since I checked two S-meters and found that the coils in the meters were blown. Judging from the damage, especially the black marks on the metal equipment cases, the charge went through both the AC/DC power wires, and the the "skin" of the equipment. The rig-to-rig black marks meant that the charge arc'd several inches.
I have a bunch of equipment, although nothing is really new, and was back on the air pretty quickly although I'm still scratching my head about the mechanics of what happened.
Thanks for asking... wish I could tell you more. I haven't made any changes in the way I set things up.
Tom
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on June 18, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Thanks, Tom
One follow-up question: physically how far were the coax ends from the radios after you had disconnected them, and were those ends terminated to anything or grounded?
73
Larry
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KA4DQJ on June 18, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
The PL-259 feedline connector ends were about 4 feet from the rigs, and I didn't have them terminated into a ground.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by KG4TKC on June 20, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"It has to be a green Mason Jar"
Wouldn't Kerr jars work?
I hear tell of Mason jars, but all I ever see are Kerr jars.
______________________________
Oh,they are all about the same now. The Mason name came from the very first jars. Mason Jar is kinda like Vise-Grip,Crescent Wrench or Cadweld. First was Mason,back before the Civil War,or The War Between the States,which really opened the door to safer home preserving of food. There followed names like Kerr,Ball,and probably lots of others. Like everything else,one company owns them all now,and makes them under names like Mason,Kerr,Ball and Golden Harvest. I use a clear quart Golden Harvest Mason for my open wire feed line,,:) I have a homebrew lightning arrester outside also.
Thanks again for the well-written original article. Eham showed good taste in deciding to run it again!
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by SO8ZH on June 22, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Oh yes, we do have lightening in the Arctic. I was for many years living in North Norway up on 70 degs north and had the most fantastic thunderstorms you would dream about. Scaring ! Also I was working on JW Spitzbergen for 4 years, and thats high Arctic on 78 degs North, where we even in the middle of the dark winter had a thunderstorm with lightening and rain. Temp came up to plus 4C. Indeed very strange. Lightening scares me. My antennas always grounded when not in use.
Wishes you all a safe summer.
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by N4RRL on June 25, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
AHH Guy,... Well, as to your replies and challenges to Larry.. umm... Oh well, Never mind, replying to you is so,.. so,... ah shoot, just forget it - you wouldn't understand anyway...
Hey Larry,
Great article, very much enjoyed it and look forward to the next one and perhaps you could send some material to the Boy Scouts of America for inclusion in their handbooks. Out of all the BSA Hand Books I have read(as a scout and as a leader - both Scout Master and Assistant SM for a number of years,) I never saw that much great detail in the Hand Books.
Thanks a lot.
73 to you.
Joe
N4RRL
PS: all of us with "4" call signs are not A**HOLEs. ;-)
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by N6HPX on June 27, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
|
I recall reading in several articles over the past 40 yrs that you should just disconnect the antenna coax and put it outside the room in a place where if you do get hit it wont hurt anyone near the coax, also if you leave it inside the room it could send bolts across the room and damage anyone or anything in it. Never had it happened but did take the precaution many times as I have storms nearly every day in my area.
|
|   |
|
Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by N4DXI on July 1, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
Because of the high frequency of lightning storms here in Florida, I disconnect everything from the wall AC sockets, disconnect my coax and disconnect the Web cable. It's a pain because it takes a few minutes to reconnect everything but better than having my equipment destroyed.
In spite of that, after one severe lightning storm I found several wall warts destroyed. They were plugged into surge suppressors which in turn had been disconnected from the wall AC sockets. There was no direct hit that I could detect. My wall clock POWERED BY BATTERIES no longer worked. My relays to change antennas were destroyed however they were outside. My transceivers were, thankfully, unharmed.
I've seen lightning strikes hit a pine tree up 60 feet, split open the trunk downward then jump 20 feet to another pine tree and split open that trunk the rest of the way down. How can anything resist that type of power?
I don't ground the tip of my antennas, just disconnect. I have a friend who has outside bulkheads with antenna connects that lead into the ham shack and another set that ground the antenna. Before a storm the coax has to be manually disconnected and reconnected to the ground. According to this article, grounding the antennas is not recommended. Again, with such power, a direct strike could jump or fuse the bulkhead and still send destroying energy into the ham shack.
I like the idea of a bulkhead outside the shack and I will follow my friend's lead, but I'll still disconnect the AC, inside coax and Telephone/TV/Web cables.
73....John Bescher, N4DXI
|
|   |
|
RE: Lightning Safety
|
|
|
by K5END on July 1, 2009
|
Mail this to a friend!
|
"According to this article, grounding the antennas is not recommended."
Note: This article does not make recommendations for equipment protection.
It's a safety article intended to protect lives.
|
|   |
|
Email Subscription
You are not subscribed to discussions on this article.
Subscribe!
My Subscriptions
Subscriptions Help
Related News & Articles
Ham Radio Emergency Communications Even Possible?
Safety Isn't Just a Word
Power Line Misunderstandings
FCC Classifies Broadband Over Power Line as Information Service:
Personal Web Sites
Other Editorial Articles
The SB Project
Hamming It Up, The Early Years
Managing Ham Radio Estate Sales
How to Spot a Scam
JARL Ham Fair 2009
|