eHam.net - Amateur Radio (Ham Radio) Community

Call Search
     

New to Ham Radio?
My Profile

Community
Articles
Forums
News
Reviews
Friends Remembered
Strays
Survey Question

Operating
Contesting
DX Cluster Spots
Propagation

Resources
Calendar
Classifieds
Ham Exams
Ham Links
List Archives
News Articles
Product Reviews
QSL Managers

Site Info
eHam Help (FAQ)
Support the site
The eHam Team
Advertising Info
Vision Statement
About eHam.net



[Articles Home]  [Add Article]  

Where Do I Go from Here?

from Bob Raynor, N4JTE on December 16, 2012
View comments about this article!

"Editor's Note: Due to the popularity of some of eHam's older articles, many of which you may not have read, the eHam.net team has decided to rerun some of the best articles that we have received since eHam's inception. These articles will be reprinted to add to the quality of eHam's content and in a show of appreciation to the authors of these articles." This article was originally published on: 12/30/2011





Where Do I Go from Here?
Some thoughts on your first antenna for HF

By Bob Raynor, N4JTE

Okay so you got your ticket and passed the tech exam as your entry into the world of amateur radio, soooooo are you bored yet? Hope not, because we are finally seeing some sunspots which allow your new voice privileges to be explored on 10 meters as opposed to the two meter stuff that might not be quite what you were hoping for. BUT if you have ventured into the next step and got your General ticket, I would like to give you a basic guideline on your HF antenna possibilities and perhaps answer a few questions along the way.

Your expectations:
I have been doing the ham thing for a lot of years and my addiction to the hobby may not become the same for you, but I think it’s safe to say we all want to be heard well enough to have a qso or at least get a fake 5-9 from a DX contester after yelling back at them in a relatively short time.
That said, once on the air for awhile you will make friends and even be able to recognize their voices before hearing their callsigns! This is what keeps old farts like me and others coming back to radio at ridiculous hours, like saying hello to my friend in England G0EVY at 1am or checking in with the HHH net at 4am local to say hello to friends in Australia and New Zealand. The excitement of being able to this with some homebrew wire in the trees NEVER gets boring!

It has gotten to the point where I don’t even have to explain these bizarre hours to my xyl, got her trained, so to speak, as long as the garbage is taken out, mortgage paid, the wood chopped for the fireplace and the driveway shoveled so she can get to work; while I put up a wire beam for 80 meters halfway into my neighbors yard, all is fine in my ham world. Yeah right!

Anyway, point of this short article is to try to focus our newly licensed Ham brethren and give you folks some tried and true antenna advice before you get sucked into buying a commercial antenna you can build yourself or more importantly avoid wasting hours and money on some magic internet antenna.

Timing is Everything:
As a newly licensed ham, you have joined us after a pretty long dry spell, propagation wise.
Band conditions on the upper bands like 10, 15 and 20 meters are showing some incredible signs of life. What this means is you don’t need a $5000 tower and beam to speak to another ham half way around the world, propagation will do most of the work with the antennas I am going to describe and these conditions should last a few years, and this stuff will cost you less than you might spend for a month of internet service!

What’s your Preference?
So many frequencies and only so much time to play on the radio! Good time to make some choices, are you ultimately trying to see how far away you can be heard, or maybe you’ve got another new ham friend some miles away you want to keep in touch with? Or even maybe you are more technically inclined and want to explore antenna building or perhaps contesting? Time for you to focus a little bit, after a little while on SSB you’ll find a niche of interest, BUT; your antenna is your key element to getting it done. A $2000 radio will become an expensive doorstop without studying, reading and building the best antenna you can fit in your backyard.

My first choice in antennas has always been some configuration made from wire and usually for two bands, 40 meters and 80 meters, my reason being that a monoband antenna is easier to build and easier to match efficiently to your radio, I have designed/ reviewed various multi-band wires, see “ribbon” and “G5RV” in old eham articles under my call, but the need for a multiband antenna is probably a good thing for a new ham to explore so I will present a few. BUT; you new generals will have to take the time to research the actual dimensions and construction, this isn’t a “ how to article,” what I do want to present is what actually works and will give the most bang for the buck and get you reading some antenna theory books as opposed to advertisements. Google is our friend if you need more info on the following antennas or email me at my QRZ page.
Gonna give my choices as based on best to last preference for starter efficient antennas from my own personal experience at my location, your mileage may vary.

Multiband Homebrew Wire antennas:

CENTER FED DOUBLET

1: Put up the longest, highest, flattest center fed wire you can fit in your yard, nothing wrong with the ends hanging down near non conductive end supports to add additional length. This antenna needs to be fed with open feed ladderline and will require a tuner to match efficiently to your 50 ohm radio. If you can get at least 75% of the length of your lowest band wavelength up in the air, this antenna will make your day on a lot of frequencies. My first choice for a new ham who wants to explore a bunch of bands.

FAN DIPOLE

For shape reference only!

This kind of antenna allows the use of direct match to 50 ohm coax and should not need a tuner and will allow operation on mutibands with a little sweat equity on the construction side. Like I said in preamble, read up on this one, might fit your yard and your radio needs.

Not going to spend much more time on multi band antennas because once you have narrowed your focus as a newer ham you’re going to want to be louder than the guys using them, so next, a little time will be devoted to how to double your power out and increase that skip distance thing you memorized on your test!

Oh yeah; I GUARANTEE that either of the above antennas will work as well as or better than anything sold commercially for 10 times the price!

AND; I am aware it is a short list, counting on my antenna gurus reading this to jump in and expand!

But before someone else points out the obvious , let it be known that almost any piece of wire will get you on the air and be heard somewhere, but with a little homework you will enjoy designing something to fit in your backyard that will expand your horizons. During WW2 a little toy called a Slinky, yeah that thing, was used to successfully communicate on the battlefield! And hula hoops became super magnetic loops able to work the world at will, just kidding about that one.

SO YOU WANT TO BE LOUD WAY OUT THERE?

Well that’s going to take a little work if you are willing to play with some wire.

On the upper bands pretty much everyone has a commercial, expensive beam on some sort, on a tower, not to worry, the same can be done at nominal cost with wire. On 40 and below a wire gain antenna is the way to go and not hard to do. And once you get a little more into phased reversible wire arrays you will be truly competitive with most of the tower/ commercial store bought beam guys on ANY band.

1: YE GOOD OLD DIPOLE!

The most efficient, easy to build mono band antenna out there. Unless you are getting creamed in some contest with the big guns firing up their $20,000 stations, you will be heard, HOW?; because by hook or crook you figured out a way to get that sucker up in the air at around ½ WL on the band of your choice! If DX is your new found interest then broadside it to the NE/SW

If tight for room or lack of supports an inverted vee up as high as possible will give good results also.

Build your own and you will be amazed on any band with a dipole, especially with the emerging sunspots. The secret to DX is the lowering of your take off angle into the ionosphere and getting that first skip into the, direction/ area you’re chasing, a good high dipole can do it, other designs do it better however.

2: WIRE GAIN ANTENNAS:

It is beyond the scope of this article to explain the intricacies of multi element beam antennas like the one way up there on your neighbor’s tower.
Wire beams are relatively simple to build and extremely cheap! Commercial aluminum beams for any band are based on the property of the dipole.
By adding some correct length and spaced wires in front of, or behind, or both, of a dipole you have now focused the antenna in a narrower direction, another way to define gain.
Think of a flashlight as opposed to a candle and you will get the jist of focused energy in a specific direction.

Simple Two Element Wire Beam:

For shape reference only.

The addition of one wire 5% longer behind a dipole in the same plain will give you 3dbd of gain, in other words double your ERP; effective radiated power.
So that new 400 watt amp you saved up for will now have 800 watts going into the ionosphere. Oh yeah the extra power out works on receive also, adding an additional S unit and better signal to noise ratio for your hearing pleasure! You are focusing your transmitted signal in a smaller slice of the compass, helping diminish annoying signals off the side and the back.
This concept is applicable for every band from 2 meters to 160 meters; the spacing and between the two elements is subject to many variables and worth studying as is the possible shapes, quads, yagi, quagi etc.
The usual spacing between the wires for most gain is around .15WL.
If you have successfully built a dipole and remember the formula of 468/freq to achieve your ½ wl wire you are well on your way to using a little high school algebra to build your first beam antenna.

This process of free gain will open up an incredible arena of potential projects that will only be limited by your imagination and your commitment to studying the immutable laws of physics often contrary to a good portion of the advertisements we are all bombarded with everywhere.

Another worthy wire design is called a MOXON antenna with folded in elements that will fit where some wire beams will not. The moxon is a fun antenna and worth some serious study if you are plagued by loud stations behind you as it has very good front to back, meaning you will have an easier time hearing the station you are looking at.

Single Wire Gain Antennas:

About the only true single wire antenna that has 3db gain over a dipole is an EDZ, extended double zepp. These can be really long but if you have the room and tall enough supports this antenna will give you the same gain as a two element beam in two opposite directions. Mine has been up for years and has proven itself as the best narrow beam width single wire I have tried. Collinear antennas are a little shorter but have less gain so I stick with the EDZ.
Point being, as a new amateur either one might fit your needs so it’s worth the homework.

Getting Up In The Air:

The higher the band the smaller the antenna, nice little piece of physical law. Consider a 2 meter or a 10 meter wire beam built on the principals described above. Small enough to build and hang from any available tree and leave a string hanging from one corner to change directions, remember you built a directional beam, primitive maybe but mucho times better than the stub on your 2 meter hand held.

NO TREES ? Try something like below:

For an inverted vee or center of a dipole an easy to get 40 ft in the air pole for $50 is pictured. I use these things all the time in beam and vertical experiments They are 25ft extended and attached to a 2x4 and then to post holed 4x4, no concrete or help needed to install alone. Check fiberglass flag poles or Spider poles.

SUMMARY:

I suggest the best thing for a newly licensed ham to do is to get on the air and start chatting with people. You can ask them what antenna they are using and make your own deductions. Join a WAS net, like CCN or OMISS and see what you like or dislike about your present antenna. Determine if you have a favorite band that fits your interest and maybe upgrade to a mono band wire beam.
This article is a very cursory look at starter antennas and methods that will work great without killing your checkbook.
Once you start down the road of designing and building your own antennas you will be addicted to this very important facet of our hobby and who knows, maybe you will writing a better article in the near future!

Tnx for reading,
N4JTE

Member Comments:
This article has expired. No more comments may be added.
 
Where Do I Go from Here?  
by WW3K on December 16, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
Thanks again Bob; another wonderful article written by a "Ham's Ham!"

While I appreciate the benefits of EZNEC (and use the demo version quite often) and all the articles written from the 'antenna MODELING' perspective, Bob always seems to bring the essential REAL-WORLD perspective to his highly informative articles. And trust me, Bob has EXPERIENCE with his designs, so if it works, he's gonna tell ya it works. If it doesn't work, he'll readily admit that as well.

(Now... all I need is a "lot-stretcher" in order to fit a 40M EDZ, hihi;)!
 
Where Do I Go from Here?  
by K0JEG on December 16, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
9 cheap and easy wire antennas, presented by Ash, KQ0C, at the Ski Country ARC meeting in November:

Part 1: http://youtu.be/fkdMkX_2_pY
Part 2: http://youtu.be/O3UqfELAB0U
Part 3: http://youtu.be/lMw_VJb2lUQ
 
Where Do I Go from Here?  
by KT4EP on December 16, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
I just built my first vertical with 72 radials of varying length at the best lengths I could fit on the lot. Never had a vertical and I am happy with this one. Plus I built it myself and didn't spend a couple of hundred bucks for a commercial antenna PLUS the extra $$ for radials and etc.

I have nothing against commercial antennas, but my budget doesn't cover them.

My trusty stand-by is the 100 foot long inverted vee with the center at 52 feet. Fed with 450 ohm back to the shack but the last 8 feet is RG8x via 4:1 balun.

Great article,,, thanks
Keith
KT4EP
 
Where Do I Go from Here?  
by W4VR on December 16, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
And, I thought you were on to better things now.
 
RE: Where Do I Go from Here?  
by W8AAZ on December 16, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
And I wish I could support antennas with some decent height. I wish I had surveyed this QTH with a hams eye instead of necessity to settle on it. Been here alot longer than planned. Some day, I hope. Would rather have a decent ant. than try to brag about success having marginal contacts with a so-so ant.
 
Where Do I Go from Here?  
by NW0LF on December 17, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
I recently built a 40M OCF windom as my lot is 75 by 115 and the house sits toward the back, It is up in an inverted V configuration at 33 ft and works fine business. It's quieter than my Cushcraft R5( a hand me down)and comes down easy. When I'm done refurbishig my light duty 40' crank up and build my ultra light weight 20M mini-beam, the OCF will be hanging below it. There truly is a joy to building your own instead of buying, especially when the budget isn't there. I also built a tunable copper pipe 2M j-pole and will build a 3 el 2M quad for the tower. If nothing else, antenna building is an excuse to run off to the home improvement store for parts( and to browse around without the better half).

72, Tom, NW0LF
 
RE: Where Do I Go from Here?  
by M6GOM on December 17, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
"And I wish I could support antennas with some decent height."

I built a Moxon for 10m and it is up at only 18ft on an aluminium pole bolted to a shed. I've worked all over the world with than and 100W.
 
Where Do I Go from Here?  
by WA4D on December 17, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
"Anyway, point of this short article is to try to focus our newly licensed Ham brethren and give you folks some tried and true antenna advice"

Really? for the "newlyh licensed ham"? Pardon me for sneaking in the back door and getting a piece of this surely the best Wire antenna primer I've ever seen. Bill Orr and Stu Cowan would admire this.

Just Excellent. Thank You Bob.

mike wa4d.net
 
Where Do I Go from Here?  
by KG3Z on December 20, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
Bob,

Thanks for your continuing efforts to educate. I, for one, really appreciate the help. Merry Christmas & Happy New Year.

Tom (7068)
 
RE: Where Do I Go from Here?  
by N4JTE on December 20, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
Big tnx to mike and tom, so many new guys with no clue about what really works, appreciate the repost as a classic thing, hope the new guys read it and understood.
Amazing to me what generates mucho comments on this article thing, definetley not about usefull info, seems more like, let's see our selves on the internet!!
still building and sharing,
bob
 
Where Do I Go from Here?  
by W3TTT on December 21, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
My best antenna is a 80 meter quarter wave vertical with raised radials.

The vertical wire goes over a tree. Simple.
The base is positioned at first story roof level, at a corner of the house. Two radials go along the house walls, and the other two radials go away from the house.

I use a MFJ antenna tuner, and it tunes to every band except 160 meters (still working on that). SWR 1:1 on every band, and good reception reports.

The advantages over a dipole: only one support, no need to "strech" the wire, and low-angle transmit lobes, good for DX.

And on the subject of "Where do I go from here?" My advice is CW. Try it - you will like it.

Thanks
Joe W 3 T T T


 
Where Do I Go from Here?  
by W9KDX on December 29, 2012 Mail this to a friend!
I have a multiband OCF dipole and a fan array for 12-15-17 meters, just high enough to be within specs. I reach my limits at 8500 miles around the globe and I won't have a chance at Antarctica until the next cycle, and of course, when a high demand station gets swamped with calls, I am drowned out. But I won't trade my setup any time soon. I have all the fun I need and I can hear stations I have no business hearing.

Good old Dipole works for me.
 
RE: Where Do I Go from Here?  
by KG3Z on January 4, 2013 Mail this to a friend!
Bob hit on a really good point: the understanding part. I'm about as new to licensing as you can get-4 years. Been around the edges of radio since a teenager in the 60's and in technical disciplines my entire adult life, so I THOUGHT I would understand. Turns out I need to see and experience things to really understand them. That or a slap up side the head. SO when I was reading about antennae and noise, I said..yep I understand that. Problem was I needed a frame of reference to work from, and that was a problem. Living in a middle unit townehouse with HOA covenants meant no beam, in fact nothing could be visable from the front at all. Lots of research and my own housing situation led me to an End Fed Wire Antenna - the EFWA oriented N-S. I also got myself on the architecual committee in charge of antennae. Read about the noise and how difficult the EFWA can be, but I pushed on and shot a 148' wire directly out the back porch, across a pond into the trees. It sloped from about 20 feet at the feed, to 40' at the far end. Built my own feed point transformer and was ready to work the world. Stop: Little Darn Good 100 weight tuner could not match it-but it wasn't designed to- as I now start learning impedance matching. This antenna worked many countries, but noise level was really high. BUT I thought that was just the way it was, the area is just noisy. After 3 years I decided it was time for something different; just to experiment. I drove myself nuts with formuals, analysers, resonnant legnths. Finally I used one of Bobs' theories: put up as much wire as you can. SO I put up 180' dipole (started out as 200' but I had a problem with the measure twice, cut once idea--did it the other way around) got it up about 60', oriented E-W and fed it with about 125' of window wire right to the transmatch. Now re-learned about impedance matching since My Favorite Jewel 993B wouldn't match this antenna. Found a Nye-Viking MB-IV and started learning about matching 'the old way' (Now I know how the old corner organ grinders felt). SOOO after a lot of experimentation, teeth grinding and head slapping--WAS IT WORTH IT??--YOU BET IT WAS!!! Now I have a point of reference for noise: I dropped from a constant S7-9 down to S2, and can hear stations never heard from before. Not satisfied there, I A/B'd the antennas to the point of wearing the lettering off the button- just to make me smile. I guess the point of all the rambling is for the Hams newer than me--don't be afraid to experiment, even if it doesn't work, you'll learn something..even if its wrong. But you have so much to Gain.


73,
Tom-KG3Z
 
Email Subscription
You are not subscribed to discussions on this article.

Subscribe!
My Subscriptions
Subscriptions Help

Related News & Articles
DXE-ATSA-1 Works on 160 Meters
2-Element Bent Dipole Yagi


Other Antennas Articles
DXE-ATSA-1 Works on 160 Meters
2-Element Bent Dipole Yagi