small anttena for vx-7r ---- need opinion

[4Z7GBA]

hallo
i want to buy a new Small antenna for yaesu vx-7r

i find too anttenas

dimond    srh-805s
and
comet      sma501 ducky


i want your opinion on this too anttena
witch is better ?

about the dimond i herd that there is fake   
how can i know i what i buy is real or fake ?

 

[K7KBN]

Whatever you get, add a "tiger tail" as shown on this link.

http://www.hamuniverse.com/htantennamod.html

[4Z7GBA]

what do you recomend

what to buy the dimond or the comet

[K7KBN]

No recommendation from me - any rubber duckie on any HT is going to have less than stellar performance.  The Tiger Tail can, and does, help.

[KB1GTX]

how about a diamond srh815

It will go more range and is 6 inch tall.

[4Z7GBA]

i have this
i also have the original
and another motorola anttena with a sma to bnc connector

i want some thing small

long one not comfteble
stuck in my shirt or my phone and the vx7 fall down

[KG4RUL]

Looking at available, published specs, neither one stands out.  To reiterate, you are likely to be disappointed with the performance of either antenna on VHF frequencies, at other than line-of-sight distances.

[K7KBN]

In most cases, including this one, the smaller the antenna, the worse the performance and the more disappointed you're going to be.

[4Z7GBA]

i am going to try a difrrent anttena with tiger tails
what i have is to tuff and it stuck in my shirt all the time and the vx7 fall to the flore
srh805 is it good
i have somthing like it but more tuff