I have not operated both BUT. The people that have mostly say that the whip and base loaded tuner is a few (about 3 or or even more) dB down from a screwdriver. That don't mean it won't work, it just won't work as well as a coil up from the base like a screwdriver has. I agonized over this these two choices myself for a long time before going with the screwdriver. I have the Little Tarheel II and really like it. I did replace the 32 inch whip with a 48 incher. It does help. The UnUn and whip will be a few dB down from the 102 inch whip and Tuner. If there was something better than the center loaded antenna with a whip as much as you can stand, then everyone would be using it. As for the Baby tarheel, it does not cover 80 meters. Of course 80 meters is not a great mobile band, as the efficiency is very low. I use it occasionally with the Little Tarheel II and it works fair down there, But If I had to give up a band, that would be the one.