Its nice to see that someone else has tried this array. I know it used to be very popular, but its funny how little I can find about it using Google.
I do know that the Moxon Rectangle has also been very popular - and I have had great success with it. I have also owned a TA-33, MA5B and SteppIR 2 element.
My present DXCC needs make the W8JK the right tool for the job.
I can see where an A3S would be better than any 3 element beam, but I actually wanted a wire antenna with gain, fixed and pointed NE - SW. I tried a 20M half square, but the W8JK is definately much better.