Manager


Manager - NA4M
Manager Notes

Reviews For: Practical Wireless

Category: Amateur Radio Periodicals

eMail Subscription

Registered users are allowed to subscribe to specific review topics and receive eMail notifications when new reviews are posted.
Review Summary For : Practical Wireless
Reviews: 20MSRP: £2.95
Description:
British Magazine: General Ham Radio News, Reviews and Construction Articles.
Product is in production
More Info: http://www.pwpublishing.ltd.uk/index.html
# last 180 days Avg. Rating last 180 days Total reviews Avg. overall rating
00203.1
VK2WTT Rating: 2021-07-02
High quality, relevant content with a nice iPad app Time Owned: more than 12 months.
I've been a subscriber to the digital version of PW for several years now, and have always found each publication to be feature-packed and of high quality. There is a good balance of subject matter and the new product reviews are timely. In the age of endless free online content, a professionally produced publication of this quality is still well worth paying for. The iPad app also works really well. Highly recommended.
KB9MWR Rating: 2020-03-19
Poor with Warners Groups Publications Time Owned: more than 12 months.
I usually buy archive CD's of the UK magazines to keep tabs on things overseas. A couple years ago Practical Wireless switched from PW Publishing to Warners Groups Publications. Last year I paid in advance for their year end CD that was to be out by the end of Jan. I took follow-up emails and then I had if my April. This year the CD was cracked, and the replacement they sent was the wrong year. Aside from that, the content is still pretty good.
G3VGR Rating: 2011-02-13
Good magazine Time Owned: 6 to 12 months.
I gave "Camm's Comic" a good slating on here back in 2002. It's changed considerably since then and has become a very well balanced magazine. It's now a far better read than the RSGB's dumbed down "RadComic" and serves UK Radio Amateurs very well.
All credit to Rob Mannion and his sterling work with PW

----------------------
Earlier 1-star review posted by G3VGR on 2002-11-12

This is a very lightweight magazine nowadays and not worth the money. I haven't found the need to buy it for a long time, a 5 minute browse in WH Smiths is sufficient. Without the hard work of Rob Mannion, this publication would probably disappear.
GM6HGW Rating: 2008-05-13
Good value Time Owned: more than 12 months.
I’ve been buying PW since the 1970’s. It’s difficult for a magazine to cover all facets of our hobby, but I think the team at PW does try. If you look back through the letters page, you’ll see that the editor is happy to print critical letters concerning the standard of articles and areas covered, how many editorial teams do this?

As for constructional articles, if PW publishes complex projects, the team come under fire from novices and newcomers. If the projects are too simple for advanced amateurs, criticism is levelled for dumbing down.

The editorial team appears to welcome readers’ comments and feedback. Additionally how many editors of hobby related publications go to major rallies and even humble local clubs to give talks, meet local amateurs and fly the flag of their publication?

PW is printed on good quality paper in clear text which I can read without my reading glasses. It tries to keep up to date and gives space over to news items as well as constructional projects at all levels.

As for the space given over to adverts, look through issues dating back to the 70’s and you’ll see that the proportion of space given over to advertisement was just as high then as it is now.
DL3GAZ Rating: 2007-04-10
25 years later Time Owned: 0 to 3 months.
I enjoyed PW on a regular basis until 1982 when I moved to Germany. Now, 25 years later, I had the opportunity to study a current issue (Jan. 2007) and found it as interesting and filled with profound knowledge as back then. Keep on the good work!
VE3ES Rating: 2007-04-03
Good British publication Time Owned: more than 12 months.
Nice publication if you're looking to add to your collection of QST, CQ, TCA, etc. Geared towards British ham radio ops but a pretty good read for those of us on this side of the pond.
EI2GLB Rating: 2006-02-21
needs to be updated Time Owned: more than 12 months.
i have being buying pw since 1994 i was only 14 back then and used to count down the days till it came out when i finally got licened in 2004 i stopped buying it as i got sick of the page after page articles on valves and simple projects i started buying it last year (2005) and guess what its the same and even worse the reviews are totally useless there is only one reviewer who has a proper station. everthing is aimed at the older age group im only 26 i want to read about amplifiers large beams dx'ing how to build a 4 square for 80m stuff like that not how to make a one freq cw transmitter is a sweet tin (and before anyone thinks damm young person knows nothing i have two college quailfactions in electronics and service and repair multi million doller semi conductor manufacturing machines every day)the need a new lease of life valves are gone so forget about them the average ham walkes into a shop and buys his radio and antenna he should be catered for as well as the person who wants to build his own radio.
on a plus the quailty of advertising is very good only for it i would never buy it
G4DYO Rating: 2005-08-13
It's OK and useful Time Owned: N.A.
I agree that the mag is different to what it was 40 years ago, but radio has changed. I came back recently after a 7-year break and found the bands empty so a lot of interest has obviously gone, and with it those who write articles for mags. I occasionally purchase a copy, primarily for the adverts but do find some articles of interest.

To those who are not satisfied I say "Why don't YOU contribute something to the magazine?" Contributions will probably be welcomed with open arms and, who knows, someone out there might just be waiting for what YOU can offer..
SMHAM Rating: 2005-08-12
Not nearly as good as it used to be Time Owned: N.A.
PW was the first foreign ham magazine I bought back in the seventies. It was very hard to come by in Sweden back then but I found it in a shop run by two old ladies. Back then PW was not very well known in Sweden and few hms bought it. Therefore PW was hard to come by. Apparently my interest and recommendation to others made the old ladies keep it on their shelves. "It must be a good magazine, we sell about 10 copies every month and only a few of the other ones" I remeber them saying. They had CQ and QST as well.

Back then it was really inspiring to read about all projects, not to mention the naming convention PW uses. Small villages in a foreign country came to my knowledge...

It is very sad to see the transformation of PW to a mainstream magazine. I really miss the top notch projects from ancient times. It was about amateur radio back then, not amateur communication. Unfortunately PW has fallen into the same category as so many other magazines. Bring back the old projects, like a transverter driver, measurement equipment etc that run over several issues.

PW was one of the very few top notch magazines in the seventies and eighties, I wish it still were.
M1FHJ Rating: 2005-08-12
Not improving Time Owned: more than 12 months.
Every month I buy a copy of PW, hoping for some improvement in the variety (and interest) of its content, but Im always dissapointed. I seem to find the same old formulaic articles month after month - the ideas do seem to have dried up, the writing is lack-lustre (and quirky) and the sparkle gone.